By Toby on July 26th, 2010
This post currently has
3 comments ·
Add a comment
St.Kilda vs Hawthorn:
Looking Good:
- Lenny Hayes: This game was perfectly suited to Lenny, who loves hard fought contests through which he can tackle all day long. His match-up on Hodge was fantastic, and he was allowed enough room to rack up 30 disposals and 11 tackles.
- Luke Hodge: Hodgey was brilliant… again! Watching him streak away from clearances, or pass off a brilliant underground handball, you simply watch him with awe. In fact, if he doesn’t win the Brownlow this year, the umpires have a lot to answer for! He finished this game with 33 touches - his mediocre 3 tackles meant he didn’t score much higher than a ton.
- Nick Riewoldt: Three games back and he is starting to look much more like his old self. Despite kicking all the Saints behinds for the night, his confidence in pack marking and chasing and harassing his opponent hasn’t waned. With the Saints’ brilliant run over the next month, he could be due for some big scores.
Disappointing:
- Sam Gilbert: Was dragged deep in defence by Osborne, so saw very little rebounding action. Opposition teams are working out how important Gilbo is to the Saints, but fortunately for them they also have Fisher and Gwilt in their arsenal, meaning they don’t need to be overly concerned when Gilbert is taken deep. He should bounce back though I would assume.
- Jordan Lewis: Continued his forward tagging role this week, however to less effect than against Brisbane last week. Unfortunately for Lewis, Sam Fisher is also a good defender in his own right, meaning that playing on him will likely mean you are left missing in action too. I was surprised though that they didn’t throw him into the guts when the game was in the balance late.
- Leigh Montagna: Was playing well until he pulled a groin muscle when he slipped on the Etihad surface. The Saints are playing a no risk policy at this time of year, so there will be plenty of nervous owners waiting to see how he trains this week.
Blip on the Radar:
- Ben McEvoy: Played one of his best games for the club, which included kicking the goal that drew the match. Whilst he does appear to have the attributes needed to be a good ball-winning ruckman, he isn’t necessarily an athletic ruckman who can win plenty of ball around the ground (i.e. Cox and Kruezer), but more of a smart ruckman who knows where to run to intercept kicks in defence, as well as kicking the odd goal when dropping forward. His scoring is hugely inconsistent, so stay well away.
Collingwood vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- Dane Swan: Another 37 touches for Swanny in another best on ground performance. I feel like I say the same thing in this article every week - the guy’s a gun. Plain and simple. If you don’t have him, you really want to start doing the maths to work out how to get him. And if you do have him, never ever ever move the ‘C’ away from his name!
- Alan Didak: Despite copping the King tag for most of the day, Dids pretty much did as he pleased, racking up 28 touches, as well as dropping forward for three bonus goals.
- Mitch Morton: Played an interesting game in the back half, rather than in his usual spot up forward. He looked confident (although I think over confidence may have been one of his issues earlier in his career) and was one of Richmond’s few highlights. I wouldn’t touch him though!
Disappointing:
- Dustin Martin: Never really got into the game until late, when he then unfortunately copped a knee in the back which put him back out of the action. He still got 17 touches, but handballed way too much.
- Jack Riewoldt:
To kick two goals on Presti you have to be doing something right! But unfortunately, it wasn’t enough to hold his lofty average, which now seems to be slipping over the past fortnight. We must remember that this is still a breakout season for him and we must take the good with the bad.
- Sharrod Wellingham: Didn’t get too involved in the party, picking up only 17 rather poor disposals. I doubt he will get dropped, but needs to stay in form to keep his spot in a side that has close to half a dozen players knocking on the door.
Blip on the Radar:
- Alex Rance: Played around the flanks for most of the game and racked up a reasonable amount of ball. However we have already seen this year he is not in the best-22 yet, so don’t be trading him in on the back of one good score, even as an emergency.
Geelong vs Brisbane:
Looking Good:
- Joel Selwood: Selwood has been the in-form Cat midfielder over the past month, and again played in amazing fashion, racking up a huge 41 disposals, 9 marks and 10 tackles, culminating in the biggest score of the round.
- Gary Ablett Jnr: Interestingly played a lot more time in the forward line, and although finishing with just 26 disposals, his work up forward netted him five goals, resulting in his large score. I have a suspicion he is a little underdone at the moment, but if he can rest up forward and kick five goals, I’m happy for him to see out the season up there!
- Jack Redden: I really, really rate this kid - he is smart and tough and knows how to find the ball. Whilst Brisbane have a number of young midfielders coming through their ranks, this kid is my favourite. He finished this game with 25 touches and 10 marks - great figures for a player of his age against an opposition of such quality.
Disappointing:
- Corey Enright: This is the third week now that Enright has made the disappointing list… Once again a forward tag has shut him down and once again he did very little about it, finishing with just 19 disposals. He MUST improve, or plenty of coaches are going to get very burned!
- Brendan Fevola: I think it is time that we resigned to the fact that the Fevola trade is the worst thing to happen to Brisbane - he has been a spud of the highest order this year and looks nowhere near getting any better. His body language lets the rest of the team down and he deserves to be dropped. I’m sure Brisbane wish they could have their time all over again.
- Daniel Rich: Was shut down by Ling and had zero effect on the match, finishing with just 12 touches. 2010 just hasn’t been his year.
Blip on the Radar:
- David Wojcinski: Wojo has never been and will never be a good dream teamer. He is a role player for Geelong and has good run and carry skills with his great pace. In thrashings like this one, his scoring tends to lift with his team, but this is not something you should expect consistently from him.
Essendon vs North Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Andrew Swallow: Swallow was again prolific through the midfield - he has worked so hard to become a player capable of the tough stuff, as well as being able to spread wide and create an option for his teammates. Not only does this allow him to plenty of the ball, but also helps him get to damaging spots on the ground, such as the forward line, where he has become able to kick a few goals.
- Jobe Watson: Watson is thriving under the captaincy, racking up over 40 touches as the best player for his team on the night. He has got a real good footy head on him and knows how to get the best out of himself - with these traits he will rarely have a bad game.
- Kyle Hardingham: Hardingham was the story of the night - he was a mature aged rookie taken by Essendon in the pre-season draft last year and played the game as a forward. As it seems, he has a great set of hands on him and can kick at goal pretty accurately. He finished the night with four goals and a contender for mark of the year. You can pick him up as a midfielder for just under $100k.
Disappointing:
- Daniel Wells: In one of the stranger stories of the weekend, owners of Wells would have been mighty disappointed when he strained his quad with the last kick of the warm up. Obviously, he couldn’t play, but plenty of owners would have been very happy the Roos were able to bring Hale into the squad, meaning you weren’t left with a big fat zero from Wells which would actually count as his score.
- Brent Prismall: Came in as a late inclusion and made a few blues that didn’t help his cause to stay in the team. I don’t understand why he keeps getting dropped, but I wouldn’t be expecting him to survive after an average performance like this one.
- Ben Cunnington: I know he is still a kid, but the best DT scoring player through the TAC cup has certainly been a bit of a disappointment this year. He is showing signs he will be a good player in the future, but is currently not winning enough of the ball.
Blip on the Radar:
- Levi Greenwood: Greenwood had less of a role to play than usual so spent chunks of time on the ball, leading him to his biggest score of the year. Don’t be expecting too many like this though.
West Coast vs Carlton:
Looking Good:
- Kade Simpson: Was the Blues best midfielder on the night, despite wearing a close tag. Finished with 33 disposals and 12 marks for the game, easily the best on ground.
- Andrew Strijk: Strijk was particularly good early until a high bump ruled him out later in the game. Was one of West Coast’s best players, with his strong runs and pin-point forward entries a highlight. He looks to be a real find for the Eagles.
- Marc Murphy: Murphy finished with just 26 disposals, but his two late goals were the sealers for the Blues. He still doesn’t seem to be playing at his best, but I’d still take 106 points from him anyday!
Disappointing:
- Dean Cox: Cox was really average, after impressing over the past fortnight. He finished with just 8 touches and 16 hitouts, playing second fiddle to Naitanui.
- Robert Warnock: Those hoping this game would galvanise his spot in the team may have been a little worried when he racked up just 10 disposals for the game - 9 of which were handballs. He was also beaten in the ruck contests by Naitanui.
- Ashton Hams: Had another decent game, but a high bump on Armfield that sent him to hospital will be looked at very closely. Could be looking at a few weeks on the sidelines.
Blip on the Radar:
- Shaun Grigg: Grigg had a reasonable game playing around the midfield and half-forward line. He plays well as a ball-winner, but my worry is that we have seen this same scoring from him in previous seasons, only for him to pull out plenty of mid-20 scores too.
Western Bulldogs vs Fremantle:
Looking Good:
- Daniel Cross: Crossy seemed to get just about every possible hard ball all day, picking up 31 touches in another dominant display. He is a great dream teamer from seasons past, yet is highly (and strangely) unheralded in plenty of DT circles. He wins plenty of ball and is a tackle machine. Consider him if you need a midfielder.
- Jarrod Harbrow: Ran around in the backline, picking up stats at will, especially in the second half when the Dogs played plenty of kick-to-kick games in the back half. Certainly a good score, but don’t be depending on these sorts of numbers from him too often in the future.
- Nick Suban: He did this last year - played the last half-dozen or so matches with aplomb, and fingers crossed he can repeat the feat this year. He was one of Freo’s better players in this game, finishing with 24 touches on the wing.
Disappointing:
- Stephen Hill: Once again tagged out of the game and had very little influence. Received no help from his teammates.
- Aaron Sandilands: Won in the hitouts, but was beaten around the ground by Hudson and Roughead. He doesn’t have too many shockers, so expect him to bounce back quickly.
- Dylan Roberton: Played up forward rather than as a rebounding defender as he has done for the past few weeks. Unfortunately, in a game that saw the ball travel into Freo’d forward line very few times, it was unlikely Roberton would score very highly.
Blip on the Radar:
- Roger Hayden: I really like Hayden as a player, but I think it’s a real shame he doesn’t play a more attacking role for Fremantle. He has great speed and creativity, but his defensiveness stifles this attribute. So until he is given a new role, expect very few scores like this one.
Melbourne vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Colin Sylvia: I’m loving Sylvia’s form recently - it has now been three plus-100 scores in a row and he has been looking very good, playing predominantly as a midfielder. He continued his recent trend in this game with 28 disposals and 7 tackles. Fingers crossed he can keep the run going!
- Adam Goodes: Speaking of good recent form, Goodes clocked in another very good game, albeit playing much more forward of centre than probably hoped. He was being tagged by Morton so kept trying to drag him to full-forward, and it worked, with Goodes kicking four goals as one of Sydney’s few influential players.
- Brad Green: Green was back playing his forward role which he is so good at - he knows exactly where to lead and is Melbourne’s best kick at goal. He finished with five goals for the game whilst rotating between a selection of opponents.
Disappointing:
- Ryan O’Keefe: What a shocking game - O’Keefe was tagged by Bruce but did virtually nothing to prevent it. He spent most of his time up forward and seemed resigned to losing the battle. He better pull his finger out soon as this display needs a lot of making up for!
- Tadhg Kennelly: Kennelly was also tagged and hardly did much of a better job than O’Keefe at breaking it. Melbourne were too good on every line and once again Sydney looked like they knew they would lose since 10 minutes into the first quarter.
- Jack Watts: It always frustrates me when a team kicks over 20 goals, yet their full-forward can only muster one of those goals. This was the case with Watts in this game, with him booting just the solitary goal from 9 disposals.
Blip on the Radar:
- James Frawley: Frawley has the potential to be a future star - whilst most of his early career he has been a strictly defensive player, he has had the odd game where he has created plenty of run from the half-back line. This was one and it was hopefully a sign of things to come from him. Unfortunately though, season 2010 is probably not an option, but certainly keep an eye on his pre-season next year!
Port Adelaide vs Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Domenic Cassisi: Cassisi was amazing through the midfield - in fact, although he finished with 28 touches, it felt more like 40, such was his presence. It was Port’s one-touch clearance work and clean hands that won them the game and Cassisi epitomised this. He also lead the way with their strong focus on tackles with a whopping 12!
- Troy Chaplin: Chaplin was great rebounding out of defence for Port, cutting off so many Adelaide forward forays and running them straight back out. Adelaide tried to shut him down but really had no answer as he finished with 26 disposals and 11 marks.
- Justin Westhoff: Westhoff was great at CHF, beating a very significant player in Bock. His four goals all came at pivotal times, and unlike his opponents, he seemed capable and confident of kicking them from anywhere.
Disappointing:
- Kurt Tippett: Was hardly sighted until he moved into the ruck in the last quarter, yet still to little avail. Whilst not doing much this year, Crows supporters can at least be excited at the potential of their young team over the next few years with the likes of Tippett, Walker, Vince, Mackay and Dangerfield all looking like potential stars.
- Taylor Walker: Had plenty of chances to get the Crows back into the game but continually missed his shots at goal, finishing with 2.4 for the evening.
- Robbie Gray: Lacked the match fitness to play such a high intensity game straight back from injury. He was also well held by Johncock, but just struggled to win his own ball. Will get better though I am sure.
Blip on the Radar:
- Matt Thomas: Thomas, aka. ‘The Crow Killer’ loves his showdowns, and it was to be expected that he would run rampant in this game. He has in fact been scoring quite well this year, but still he averages too low to really consider him for selection. He plays his roles perfectly so there is no reason for Port to play him as a more attacking player. Therefore, keep away.
This post currently has
3 comments ·
Add a comment
By Footy Tragic on July 19th, 2010
This post currently has
10 comments ·
Add a comment
Adelaide vs Geelong:
Looking Good:
- Bernie Vince: Played another great game through the midfield, further damaging my prediction of a few weeks ago that he wouldn’t come good this season. Has returned from injury well and is leading the Crows resurgence.
- Joel Selwood: Was one of only a few in-form Geelong midfielders on the night as their high-possession game plan seemed to fall by the wayside. Finished with a very impressive 35 disposals and 6 marks.
- Harry Taylor: Was fantastic in the Cats defence, mopping up plenty of Adelaide attacks. He played on a variety of younger opponents and was allowed to run off them when the likes of Scarlett and Enright weren’t. Played very well, but don’t expect too many games like this one.
Disappointing:
- Corey Enright: Second week in a row he has stunk it up so he tops my disappointing list. He used to be Mr. Consistent, but has lately been finding himself tagged out of games with the likes of Hunt and Taylor taking up his rebounding responsibilities in the process. Should really come good soon - I think it is more coincidence than form issues that have seen him give out two poor scores in a row.
- Kurt Tippett: Looked lively early when manned by Lonergan, but as soon as Scarlett moved to him he was held very quiet. Finished with just one goal, but it was his five frees against that really killed his score.
- Gary Ablett: Ablett finished on a respectable 81 points, but his game was quite poor by his standards. In fact, his form across the past month or so has been quite average - at this point I would not consider making him captain at all! He is getting frustrated by his game, is going to ground more and receiving less support from both his teammates and umpires. It may just be coincidence, but this Gold Coast decision certainly seems to be looming over his head.
Blip on the Radar:
- Harry Taylor: As I stated above, Taylor’s game was a great one, however not one that will likely be repeated too often this year. He is close to AA form this year, but his game does not typically involve much rebound from defence, especially with players like Scarlett, Milburn and Enright alongside him.
Collingwood vs St.Kilda:
Looking Good:
- Dane Swan: Best on ground again for Swan with 36 touches and 7 marks. He is stunning through traffic and great at finding his own space, hence being the ball-winning man that we love. He simply keeps producing. I am already salivating about him playing Richmond next week at the MCG! Especially with Jackson out suspended!
- Sam Fisher: Was the Saints best player, acting as a loose man in defence and chopping off plenty of Collingwood forward-entries. He had a whopping 18 marks amongst 33 disposals. Hopefully this can be the start of a purple patch for him.
- Dale Thomas: Was great all day, but especially in the second half when Collingwood started displaying their party tricks. Played through the midfield all day again and is still keeping his consistency up with 27 disposals and 12 marks. He won’t ever sell a dummy to Hayes again though…
Disappointing:
- Farren Ray: Played as a small defender on the repositioned Heath Shaw and lacked any sort of rebound. Has been ultra consistent since crossing from the Dogs, so it is a shame to see him have a bit of a shocker.
- Stephen Milne: Just the one goal for Milne, and it was a gift from Pattison. He simply struggles in big games, and proved it here with another poor showing.
- Chris Dawes: Was held pretty tight by Dawson and only kicked the one goal for the game. Saints have got a typically good record on Tall forwards, and with no Cloke to act in support, Dawes’ game wasn’t necessarily a surprise.
Blip on the Radar:
- Jarryn Geary: Has been a good developing player for Saints, but is more of a role player than a ball winner. This season he has switched from defence to defensive forward each week, with this game seeing him given a role as the latter. The Saints often played through him to keep his opponent accountable, but it is not a typically high scoring role, nor one we will see him in consistently.
Hawthorn vs Brisbane:
Looking Good:
- Jordan Lewis:
Played again on the half forward flank and kicked a bag of four goals, including three in the first quarter. His role was a defensive one of Travis Johnstone, but to keep Johnstone accountable, the Hawks regularly went through Lewis to get into the forward line, hence his massive score. He plays this role very well, suggesting this is where he will play out the season from.
- Brad Sewell: Sewell was dropped in selection this week due to his continued poor form, but was given a reprieve when Buddy was a late withdrawal. Sewell came out swinging, finishing with 39 disposals and 6 tackles - a huge increase on what he has been dishing out up until now. Whilst I wouldn’t pounce on him yet, if he can recapture his 2009 form he is currently dirt cheap.
- Wayde Skipper: Played his best game for the Brown and Gold, making plenty of owners thankful that Hille had reinjured his hamstring. Whilst he wasn’t prolific, he showed good ball winning skills and a good set of hands. Kicked a nice goal too which was some good icing on the cake.
Disappointing:
- Jonathan Brown: In his first game in over a month, Brown showed that he will likely take a few weeks to adjust back to the pace. He kicked three goals but did very little else, being well held by Gibson.
- Brendan Fevola: Only three possessions and a goal for Fev this week, showing the three goals against the Saints last week was simply a blip on the radar. He is in simply shocking form and is playing with no passion or love for the Brisbane Guernsey.
- Justin Sherman: Another player deserving to be dropped from the squad after playing his fourth game of under ten disposals in a row. What’s worse is that he is actually playing a role as a ball-winning midfielder, not a tagger, so these sorts of stats are very damning.
Blip on the Radar:
- Shaun Burgoyne: Burgoyne is a star and was one of Hawthorn’s best two or three players, and will likely continue to be for the remaining rounds. Then why has he made this section? Simple - he is not a dream teamer. Whilst he will play occasional games of over 100 points, typically he will be averaging between 80 and 90, not quite good enough to be selecting at this time of year. He is a brilliant user of the ball and one of the best clearance players in the AFL, but unfortunately, Dream Team doesn’t reward either of these things and he is only an average ball-winner - the most important stat to us.
Essendon vs West Coast:
Looking Good:
- Mark LeCras: This game from LeCras was something special - he finished the game with 12 goals and two behinds - a total of 76 points worth of scoring, or an incredible 118 points worth of DT points if you count the kicks he made to kick the goals! It was an amazing effort and brilliant to watch as Essendon interchanged four opponents on him to no avail.
- Matt Priddis: Priddis controlled the midfield all night, especially in the second and third terms as he pushed West Coast towards the win. He is such a good dream teamer, finishing with 32 touches and 6 tackles.
- Dean Cox: Without wanting to speak too soon, Cox looks to be coming into a bit of form over the past fortnight. As Naitanui begins to tire, Cox’s body seems to be getting fitter with every week - he ended this game with 18 disposals and 7 marks as one of West Coast’s better players.
Disappointing:
- Patrick Ryder: Paddy has really dropped off over the past month, mirroring Essendon’s poor form. Whether he is waiting for Hille to return, or the lack of forward entries are hurting him, I am unsure, but one thing I am sure of is that I would avoid bringing him in after a couple of poor performances in a row.
- Beau Waters: Played another negating role in the backline, killing his dream team potential. After his massive purple patch a month ago it is hard watching his scoring peter away - hopefully it can return for the finals.
- Jay Neagle: After a good game last week, this game he was kept very quiet by Schofield, proving he is not a player for your DT.
Blip on the Radar:
- Ben Howlett: Nearly cracked the ton, but got a lot of the ball in the final quarter junk time. Don’t get too sucked into this one large score though, he is bench cover at best - we all know Knights’ selection policy, so therefore it is probably best to keep well away.
Western Bulldogs vs Port Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Daniel Cross: Crossy was the Dogs best, and as is his usual trademark, he was hard all day, helping himself to 33 hard-fought disposals, which also included 14 marks (well up on his average). He is super consistent and a great option heading to finals if you do need a midfielder.
- Matthew Boyd: Speaking of consistency, Boyd was brilliant again, winning plenty of ball through the middle and also dropping forward of centre to snag himself two goals. Strangely unheralded, Boyd is hardly a step behind Dream Team stars such as Montagna and Swan.
- Kane Cornes: In his 200th game it was fitting that Cornes ran around picking up ridiculous amounts of disposals, as has been his trademark for his previous 199 games. He finished with 35 disposals for the game and a bonus two goals.
Disappointing:
- Cameron Hitchcock: Hitchcock has been a godsend to plenty of forward benches this year but is fading fast. Unfortunately, the AFL season is a long one and takes its toll on younger players like Hitchcock. He was hardly sighted in this game, picking up just the 9 disposals.
- Daniel Giansiracusa: Gia, for me, has been one of the most frustrating players in DT 2010 - his new role in the forward line has been less than beneficial as his points have varied between mid-40’s, all the way to over 150 points! He gives off too many goals and I don’t think his hands are good enough to play as a key forward, so I’m praying for a cameo midfield role though the finals series… somehow I think I’m going to be disappointed.
- Jay Schultz: Possibly took mark of the year, but was unfortunately well held other than that. I think he would be a great third tall forward but struggles as the key target. He did still kick two goals on Lake though - certainly better than most!
Blip on the Radar:
- Nathan Eagleton: Eagleton is very close to being the 22nd player selected at the Dogs - he is an exclusively outside player, something that the Dogs have in abundance. He is able to find the ball, but his form wavers quite frequently, meaning he is not an ideal selection, this end of the season, or even at the start.
Carlton vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Adam Goodes: Once again playing through the midfield, and once again best on ground. He is thriving on his returned responsibilities, now with only occasional time spent in the forward line. Could easily average over 100 for the remaining rounds if this role continues.
- Bryce Gibbs: Gibbs followed Goodes around most of the day and won plenty of his own ball too, finishing with 24 disposals and 6 tackles. He’s still not playing great footy, but is at least building to some good form - hopefully he can sustain some scores over 100 throughout the DT finals.
- Heath Grundy: After a number of weeks of average scores, Grundy clocked up his first ton in a while. He played in defence and helped run plenty of the ball out alongside Malceski and Kennelly. Whilst the oppositions lack of pressure certainly helped, hopefully the Blues have played him back into some form.
Disappointing:
- Lachie Henderson: Was largely ineffective again, finishing with just the five disposals. It has to be remembered that he is a project player and will take a couple of years - at least he is playing better than Fev!
- Paul Bower: Bower played a purely defensive role, ruining his own DT scoring in the process. I’m totally confused about Bower’s season - either his role seems to change every week, or he is injured. Maybe a good 2011 prospect, but I would still be hesitant.
- Brett Kirk: Kirk is a great player, but he plays for the Swans, not your Dream Team. He is one player who looks like he wouldn’t give two stuffs about DT - if he finishes with two disposals and his opponent the same, then he is happy. His point scoring fluctuates as much as anyone, so he is not the type of player you want in your side.
Blip on the Radar:
- Shaun Grigg: Grigg has been in and out the the side all year (more so out), and will likely to continue to be as the Blues continue to fix their forward line on the run. He plays a half-forward role, but can be as inconsistent as hell.
North Melbourne vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- Leigh Adams: Racked up the ball all day on a forward flank, finishing with 28 disposals and 3 goals. The Roos regularly used him across the half-forward position and he was a strong reason for their win.
- Daniel Connors: Continued his great recent form with another 30 possession game coming out of the backline. He is almost becoming too good to start on your bench with three scores in a row over 115 points.
- Andrew Swallow: Got the hard stuff all day and fed all his fellow midfielders with his superb pack-work. Racked up 31 touches and 8 tackles for the game.
Disappointing:
- Trent Cotchin: Was well held by Greenwood, managing only the 12 touches. His game was further soured by a head-high hit on Wright, which will unfortunately likely see him suspended, despite it being totally accidental. This will be a big talking point in the media this week.
- Aaron Edwards: Has been dominating in the VFL, but just couldn’t mirror the form to AFL level, finishing with only a handful of disposals. May find himself looking for a new club at season’s end.
- Jack Riewoldt: Grima did a great job of holding Riewoldt to just the three goals and 8 disposals. Unfortunately, he can’t dominate every week, especially when his midfield is thrashed.
Blip on the Radar:
- Jake King: If you got points for trying hard, King would be a must have addition to your Dream Team. But unfortunately, trying won’t get you too far in DT - he is a tagger, nothing more, and is not a player you want in your team, ever!
Fremantle vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Paul Duffield: Duffield rarely dominates a game, but he drifts in for several key plays through the game, and every time he always ends with a beautiful pass into the forward line, a great run down the wing, or a great tackle - he is becoming a great player, and a very consistent one at that. Finished with 22 disposals, 7 marks and 6 tackles.
- Colin Sylvia: He started up forward, but was quickly, and fortunately, moved into the midfield for most of the game. He had some good passages and was particularly prevalent when the Dees were getting back into the game. He even got himself a 14-pointer, which was a sight for sore eyes (tackle, free kick, kick, goal = 14).
- Jack Watts: I really wanted to single this kid out for a very impressive game - the stats don’t speak the whole story here, but his workrate up through the midfield and along the wings was first-rate. He followed up plenty of his hard work for some one-twos and looks very ready to lead the Dees young forward line. If he had a bit more meat on the bones he would command a real presence I think - I’m really excited about the future of this kid!
Disappointing:
- Brent Moloney: Was tagged out of the game early by McPhee and really struggled, managing just 16 points in two and a half quarters of footy. He then got a corked thigh in the third, for which he was put in cotton wool - I think he could have kept playing, but was having no effect on the game so was therefore rested.
- Ryan Crowley: Played as a tagging forward and also as a small defender in bursts and it killed his scoring. Whilst he is not typically a big scorer, 26 points is well below what should be expected.
- Mark Jamar: Jamar competed well against Sandilands in the ruck, but struggled for much effect around the ground. In fact, Johnson was the most dominating ruckman around the ground.
Blip on the Radar:
- Joel MacDonald: I like Joel, but I think he is way too much on the cusp of selection at Melbourne. The Dees want to play the kids, so the senior players only need to give the slightest excuse to be dropped. Grimes back in a couple of weeks will also put some pressure on him.
This post currently has
10 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on July 12th, 2010
This post currently has
7 comments ·
Add a comment
Port Adelaide vs Collingwood:
Looking Good:
- Dane Swan: Despite being the focus of a mid-week interview where he told the interviewer that possession numbers were not important to him, he proved that secretly he does love being number one on the stats sheet and we will continue to love him for it. Finished with 39 touches and 7 tackles, with 16 of those disposals coming in a mega second term!
- Scott Pendlebury: Pendlebury was a strong competitor and only fell short of the ton by a bit. Needs to kick the ball more for such a damaging user by foot, but the fact he was able to rack up 30 disposals was still a great thing.
- David Rodan: Port’s best player, especially in the second half, where his three goals really kept the Power in the contest. Was at his zippy best and won 26 disposals with 8 tackles.
Disappointing:
- Jack Anthony: Again played the swingman role, which is killing his scoring. He looked good in a couple of passages through the middle but did little else. Could also be in trouble for a high hit late in the game.
- Matt Thomas: Sacrificed his own game to tag Daisy Thomas, yet still didn’t nullify him. Tried every trick in the book to ‘accidentally’ hurt Thomas, but fortunately it was to no avail.
- Travis Cloke: Was quite anonymous for most of the night with Dawes the main tall target in the Collingwood forward line. Was also reported in the first quarter, which at worst would see him miss a week.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brett Ebert: Ebert was on fire in the first quarter, kicking three goals and racking up plenty of the ball up field - in fact, nearly half his DT points were acquired in the first term. Ebert has proven this year that at best he is an inconsistent scorer - he has the ability to break a game open as he showed here, but all too often his massive head seems to weigh him down too much, causing some very low scores.
Geelong vs Hawthorn:
Looking Good:
- Jimmy Bartel: Jimmy was great through the middle playing a classic ‘Bartel’ game - plenty of disposals, lots of tackles and a good number of marks. He was best on ground in this tight affair and continues to prove why he is such a loved DT figure!
- Lance Franklin: Kicked another three goals, but again his work around the half-forward line was class - finishing with 22 disposals as a key forward is fantastic, even in today’s day and age.
- Paul Chapman: Chappy started hard before fading through the middle of the game as Gibson, his direct opponent, began to get on top of him, but fortunately he came home strong, finishing with 24 disposals, 7 tackles and 2 goals.
Disappointing:
- Corey Enright: Had a heavy forward tag given to him by Lewis, meaning Mr.Consistency scored his lowest score for the season. With the constant opponent he just wasn’t allowed the freedom or space to rack up his usual cheap ball, nor one-twos out of the backline.
- Xavier Ellis:
If I were an Ellis owner I would be so sick of him by now - so often he starts games strongly before fading away in the second half. In this game, at quarter time he was the second highest point getter on the ground with 33 DT points - he then went on to rack up just 21 points for the rest of the game. Disappointing and frustrating stuff.
- Jarryd Roughead: Once again the Buddy showed prevented Roughy from having0 much effect on the game as he constantly played decoy to Franklin’s leads. He finished with two goals, but it should have been more when playing on a lower-grade defender such as Lonergan.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brad Ottens: Ottens returned this week from his extended stint on the sidelines with injury and competed well. My worry though is going to be how long he will last before re-injuring himself. He has such a poor injury history that he is simply not worth the risk of bringing into your team. Don’t even give the notion a thought - I’d trade Mark Blake in before Ottens and that’s saying something!
West Coast vs Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Ricky Henderson: He’s only played a few games, but he was sensational across all four quarter as a ball-winning half-forward. He kicked three goals and racked up 22 disposals, making plenty of coaches with him as emergency happy when Goddard withdrew later that night.
- Kurt Tippett: Tippett turned this game all on his own off his own boot in the last quarter when the game was still up for grabs. He looked so powerful in the forward line and both marked and kicked very strongly - two features of his game that haven’t been so brilliant this year. He could perhaps be on the rise and a good late-season smokey to come good for finals.
- Matt Rosa: Was given the freedom to be his own player this week instead of having to follow an opponent’s tail as a tagger and he thrived with the opportunity, as he has shown several times before. I wouldn’t trade him in this year, but I am certainly penning his name into my watch-list book for 2011.
Disappointing:
- Josh Kennedy: Only kicked the two behinds whilst being totally dominated by Rutten. The lack of quality delivery is really going to make it hard for him to beat a strong opponent such as Rutten.
- Phil Davis: For those who own Davis, now is the time to stop playing him on the field - whilst he was a good scorer for a few weeks, he is now being given exclusively shut-down roles, meaning his scoring has been very poor. He is certainly playing his role in the team, but unfortunately this is not going to help your Dream Team.
- Andrew Strijk: As seems to be an odd trend with 2010 debutants, Strijk had an average third game, punishing those who brought him into their squad for his ‘bubble’ game. I doubt he will lose his spot, but that won’t help those coaches who lost their games by a small margin.
Blip on the Radar:
- Everyone from West Coast: I don’t mean this to sound as harsh as it does, but at this stage of the year, avoid trading in any players from teams on the bottom of the ladder - especially the likes of West Coast who are going to have to start playing the kids to show how bright the future is to the members. We saw them make five changes this week - proof that there won’t be a consistent lineup in the Eagles for the remaining rounds.
Brisbane vs St.Kilda
Looking Good:
- Leigh Montagna: Was the Saints best, especially in the second quarter. Watching him closely, he is such a hard worker, running from contest to contest, it is no wonder why he scores so much every week.
- Simon Black: The Saints chose to focus their tagging attention to Power, allowing Black to run free, which saw him be one of the most damaging midfielders on the ground, racking up 29 touches, 9 marks and 7 tackles - all huge stats.
- Daniel Rich: His lack of form through the midfield has seen Voss move him to defence, a move that may just turn his season around. He was great, matching up on one the Saints small forwards and playing a rebounding role, with his great disposal off half-back really helping the Lions solve their recent issue of clean disposal out of the back half.
Disappointing:
- Justin Sherman: Was hardly sighted through the whole game - in fact I couldn’t even tell you where on the ground he played as I saw such little of him. Just 6 disposals is poor - especially for a player who wasn’t even tagged.
- Jack Steven: Seemed to suffer a bit from game time and lacked the luck that has seen him snag some vital goals the past couple of weeks. Will hopefully stay in the squad as his forward pressure has been great - also, his arrival has allowed Schneider to move into the midfield.
- Jason Gram: Played just over 60% game time in his first game back from injury. He floated in and out of the game, but clearly struggled to adjust to the pace for most of the game. Will be better after a few games back, but may need some time.
Blip on the Radar:
- Amon Buchanan: Didn’t have much of an opponent in the Saints backline as Fisher and Gilbert preferred to rebound than pay him attention. He has already shown this year though that he is not a viable DT option. He COULD have been a 2010 bargain, but fortunately not too many fell for the trick.
Richmond vs Fremantle:
Looking Good:
- Daniel Connors: AGAIN, he looked great off half-back and through the middle - This kid plays like he has some drive now. The past few years he has always seemed talented, but quite possibly be one of those players who doesn’t put in the yards and misses out on really making it. This year since his drinking indiscretion, Connors has been great, here amassing a career-high 35 disposals.
- Chris Newman: I keep saying not to pick up players from bottom teams, but if I were to break my own rule, Newman would be the man - he has been really consistent this past month or so and it simply loving being the Richmond captain at such an exciting time. His work off half-back is great and he also has the ability to play through the midfield - almost like Pavlich… but a defender.
- Adam McPhee: McPhee was Freo’s best player, playing mainly as their loose man in defence - he cut off so many Richmond forways forward that he was almost the player that kept Fremantle from being blown out. Good to see him back in defence where he belongs.
Disappointing:
- Hayden Ballantyne: Had little effect on the game, but will be remembered as the player that gave away the crucial 50-metre penalty late in the fourth quarter to put Richmond in front.
- Ben Nason: GODDARD ISN’T PLAYING!! I NEED YOU TO PERFORM! IT’S JUST A BLOODY CUT! PUT A BANDAID ON IT AN GET BACK OUT THERE, THEN IF IT’S REALLY TOO HARD, JUST SIT BEHIND THE BALL AND PLAY KICK-TO-KICK!!
- Ryan Crowley: Back to a tagging role this week, meaning no mega quarters, heck, not even any goals!
Blip on the Radar:
- Adam McPhee: Had to give him the credit for his good game… But let’s be honest… It’s Adam McPhee…
Sydney vs North Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Adam Goodes: Paul Roos thought he’s “try something different” and throw Goodes into the midfield to try and re-invigorate him, and boy did it work! Goodes was prolific, racking up 33 touches and 11 tackles in one of the best individual games of the weekend. The only worry is that he was put back forward late in the game (and kicked three match-winning goals!), with Roos later hinting that this is where he would continue his season. So don’t get too excited about continued midfield time… yet.
- Tadhg Kennelly: Kennelly finally showed some form after plenty of terrible matches in a row. Running off half-back he amassed a whopping 34 disposals - his largest tally of the year.
- Nick Malceski: The Swans other rebounding defender was also having a good day at the office, equalling Kennelly’s 34 disposals. Malceski also kicked a goal, but unlike Kennelly he chose to handball more than kick.
Disappointing:
- Drew Petrie: I don’t quite understand why all these players keep getting rushed back a week too early - Petrie spent the game still clearly hampered by his foot injury and thus never got into any sort of rhythm. But by-golly, he’s gonna be cheap in 2011!
- Lachie Hansen: Although Petrie was ineffective, the Kangaroos still aimed most of their attacks at him, meaning the in-form Hansen was hardly able to trouble the statisticians. Only kicked the one behind.
- Jarrad McVeigh: The game of McVeigh was more a testament to the tagging skills of Rawlings than it was an indictment on McVeigh - so far in 2010 McVeigh has been one of the hardest men for taggers to stop with his leg-speed and great ability through traffic, but Rawlings worked hard all day to totally nullify him from the contest.
Blip on the Radar:
- Lewis Roberts-Thomson: I don’t know what it is about LRT, but he seems to suck some DTers in more than many other players. I can tell you now though that he is NOT the type of player you want. He plays the full-back role in a low-possession team, yet sometimes is allowed to junk up a bit - not Brian Lake junk (which sees a lot of points earned from reading the play) - simple, honest, “OMG I don’t wanna kick this up the middle” sort of junk stats. Stay wellllllll away!
Essendon vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Brad Green: Green started strongly with the first goal and didn’t let up from there, pushing on for best on ground honours. He finished the game with five goals, switching between half-forward and the midfield.
- Jason Winderlich: One of Essendon’s few standouts - ran hard all day and continued to rack up the pill. He finished with 30 disposals and seven marks, but really lacked much help from his teammates.
- Colin Sylvia: Made it back into the side for the first time in a few weeks and played very well, treating those owners who have kept hold of him through thick and thin. Kicked two goals amongst 29 disposals. Like Green, Sylvia rotated through the forward line and on the ball.
Disappointing:
- Patrick Ryder: Was quite easily beaten by Jamar, which was surprising. He held his own in the ruck but only managed the 10 disposals around the ground. Paddy tends to play better with Hille in the side, who should hopefully return next week.
- Kyle Reimers: Played the game as a forward and only contributed a goal. Reimers is a player who could be anything, and I think we can see this in DT land, but unfortunately his inconsistency robs him. Really needs a big pre-season next year and we could hopefully look to 2011 as a real breakout year for him.
- Paul Johnson: Was essentially a pointless inclusion as Jamar was allowed to pretty much ruck on his own anyway.
Blip on the Radar:
- Jay Neagle: Performed well with three goals, but I worry about Neagle’s consistency at his age. He won’t perform too well against top teams yet, plus he is not the type of player to be targeting at this time of year anyway.
Western Bulldogs vs Carlton:
Looking Good:
- Matthew Boyd: This guy just screams captain - gets the hard ball, uses it well, and what’s more, he does it all the way til the final siren. Will never give you half-baked effort, so expect consistently high scores.
- Bryce Gibbs: Played through the middle, which was a sight for sore eyes. He still did drop behind the ball at times, but at least he wasn’t playing a stopper’s role deep in defence. Surprisingly though, he did turn it over quite a bit - though thankfully, this doesn’t make a lick of difference to dream team!
- Brian Lake: Gee he’s good. I’ve decided to stop being so critical of him and just watch him play - and I’ve become to realise that his disposals aren’t just cheapies, but whilst not all contested, he reads the opposition kicks so well, leading to him chopping off plenty of forays forwards with his strong marking. There is no wonder he is leading the competition for marks this year - I take back every bad thing I have said, he IS a great dream team option!
Disappointing:
- Eddie Betts: No easy ball here, Eddie - 7 possessions, no goals.
- Setanta O’Hailpin: Played a shut-down role on Lake - it worked wonders, restricting Lake to just 28 touches and 8 marks… Setanta was also damaging the other way with two of his three disposals hitting the target…
- Paul Bower: His owners would have been relieved to just see him on the field playing footy, but his meagre 59 points would certainly have been disappointing. He played much more defensively orientated than earlier in the season, but as Ratten seems to change everyone’s roles each week, perhaps he will be the rebounder again next week… or maybe a small forward…
Blip on the Radar:
- Shaun Hampson: He was decent, but don’t expect his score to keep doubling every week… Expect a 60 average and not a lot more.
This post currently has
7 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on July 5th, 2010
This post currently has
3 comments ·
Add a comment
Brisbane vs Carlton:
Looking Good:
- Matthew Leuenberger: Played a super game as the dominant ruckman on the ground. He is beginning to prove his worth as a top draft pick, displaying his strong footy brain and a willingness to put his big body in dangerous spots to win the ball. He won’t clock up too many more tons this year, but this game was of a super standard.
- Chris Judd: Juddy seemed to win every centre clearance and looked to enjoy the freedom allowed to him by Brisbane - Simon Black played on him. Whilst he didn’t quite hit the ton (he was on track before going off late with the blood rule), he was the most dominant player on the ground.
- Sam Jacobs: Stepped up in Kruezer’s place and looked very comfortable and confident in this role. Is a bit of a crash-and-bash ruckman who likes to lay tackles, whilst also picking up a bit of the ball around the ground.
Disappointing:
- Shaun Hampson: Hampson played the game which all Warnock owners were wishing for - he had very little effect on the contest as a ruck/forward. He finished with just 4 disposals and 10 hitouts.
- Ash McGrath: Every time he got the ball he seemed to turn straight into oncoming track - clearly his hamstring injury effected his cognitive ability! Was really poor and turned it over constantly. Voss does have a habit of bringing players back a week too early from injury, so perhaps McGrath will come good soon.
- Luke Power: Played the majority of the game as a forward and struggled to have any effect on the contest.
Blip on the Radar:
- Andrew Walker: Walker has had a reasonable season this year, but this game (and also his past few) could prove costly to his position in the team - his current role is as a playmaker off the half-back line, but his ability to keep turning the ball over was a major issue on Thursday night, a problem which may see him given a different role, such as tagging, in the coming weeks. I would avoid him for this reason alone.
Hawthorn vs Western Bulldogs:
Looking Delicious:
- Sam Mitchell: Really led his team well at the clearances with 28 well-earned disposals, plus one of the late goals that eventually got Hawthorn across the line. His 8 tackles were also a highlight.
- Brian Lake: Ran off Franklin all night, and as usual collected plenty of cheap ball in the backline. What originally looked like a blip on the radar for Lake has turned into a consistent event - he can almost be counted on for a good regular score nowadays, thanks especially to his huge amount of marks - he finished this game with a whopping 18 marks!
- Luke Hodge: Continues on his great season after a bit of a dip last week - he played this game purely as a midfielder and finished with 28 touches and 6 tackles. Playing in a winning team is certainly helping!
Disappointing:
- Barry Hall: Kicked just two goals and did very little else, thanks to a good defensive game by Gilham.
- Michael Osborne: Was hardly sighted for much of the match as he stayed fixed to the forward line for most of the game. Finished with just 9 disposals.
- Ryan Hargrave: The trend continues - a good game last week and a shocker again this week. Was given the role as a defender on Peterson and was given little opportunity to zone off. I think it is safe to say he will likely finish off the year in similar up-and-down fashion.
Blip on the Radar:
- Liam Picken: Picken has played his year as a tagger (as he did last year), but more often than not he is taking a smaller forward, rather than a midfielder. This week though, he landed the job on Mitchell and therefore spent much more time in the midfield, allowing him to more disposals. Don’t be expecting any sort of regularity to this scoring, even if the midfield move does continue. He is a tagger first and foremost.
Fremantle vs Port Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Rhys Palmer: Was great in the midfield all day, but especially late in the match as Freo ripped the game from Port’s grasping claws. Unfortunately though, his day was soured when he shattered Barlow’s leg when going for a low mark.
- Mitch Banner: Was Port’s main architect in the second quarter as they came back strongly. He finished the game as Port’s best midfielder with 23 disposals.
- Aaron Sandliands: Carried on his great form with another dominant display. He continues to be a great go-to option for Freo, and as I have said time and time again, his contested marking is a highlight, and one that will help prevent him from getting many sub-100 scores this season.
Disappointing:
- Michael Barlow: Such a sad story to come out of this game - the injury to Michael Barlow. Those who saw it will attest to it being something they wouldn’t want to see again - the injury was graphic and clearly painful - some TV shows won’t even show the footage of him standing up afterwards, with his leg collapsing below him. A very sad story indeed after such a brave and awe-inspiring debut year from the kid… He will now miss the remainder of the season (stay tuned to www.footytragic.com to find out what to do next!)
- Daniel Motlop: He spends his time either pleading for free kicks or for his teammates to give him a cheapie out the back of packs. He needs to step back and look at how far his game has deteriorated and start learning about working hard for his disposals.
- Kepler Bradley: With Johnson’s return from club suspension, Bradley’s role was stripped back significantly and he ended up spending less time on the ball. Still played OK, but I wouldn’t be considering him now with the ambiguities Johnson’s return brings.
Blip on the Radar:
- Michael Johnson: Played his first game in a couple of months after his club suspension for drug possession. He played well as a defender-cum-ruckman, and got more than his fair share of disposals, plenty of which came from chipping around. He is not the type of player you want at this stage of the year - inconsistent and unreliable.
Collingwood vs West Coast:
Looking Good:
- Dane Swan: He just didn’t stop - and you can probably thank John Worsfold for that - after racking up 47 points by quarter time, Swan pushed on to score 161 points thanks to his 38 touches and 14 marks. He was simply prolific - in fact, it looked like there were five of him out there. He just keeps bobbing up for kick after kick, and knows exactly where to run to find the pill. He is the perfect captain.
- Darren Jolly: He proved that last week’s best on ground display was no fluke, following it up with a four goal, 20 possession game. He is clunking marks strongly and looking really good across the ground. If I had my time again, I’d trade Hille to Jolly, rather than my poor option of Cox.
- Scott Pendlebury: Despite the tag, Pendles still came to the party, racking up 27 disposals with a bonus two goals. Finally, 2010 is presenting itself as a good DT season for Pendlebury - not just Supercoach!
Disappointing:
- Chris Masten: Yes, it was his first game back from injury, but he was poor. Now averages 45 DT points over the past three games - stay well away - he is the DT antichrist!
- Beau Waters: Was given the hard forward tag by Lockyer, and it worked. He was out of the match until given the chance to junk some stats late in the fourth quarter.
- Dean Cox: He just looks to be going through the motions without really pushing himself to his full form. He doesn’t look half the player he once was and my guess is he may be rested as the season comes to an end. Don’t be as stupid as me - stay well away from this DT booby-trap!
Blip on the Radar:
- Jack Anthony: Played the game in defence and wasn’t too bad. But with the imminent inclusion of players such as Maxwell, Anthony will find himself back in the VFL very soon.
Adelaide vs Essendon:
Looking Good:
- Scott Thompson: Thompson continued his great recent form with another best on ground performance. He racked up 34 touches and 8 tackles for the game, and looks to be invigorated by Adelaide’s good recent form.
- Kurt Tippett: Is he back? Well… it certainly looked like it! After being starved of anything resembling form all year, Tippett finally looks to be the same player who finished off 2009 so strongly. He finished this game with six goals, his best for the year, whilst also picking up 16 disposals from his time in the ruck.
- Patrick Ryder: Paddy once again just fell short of the ton, but he was still impressive. He is still carrying the sole ruckman mantle at Essendon and doing it well, finishing the game as the best ruckman on the ground with a game-high 29 hitouts.
Disappointing:
- Bernie Vince: Was tagged out of the game by Welsh and couldn’t join in the party. As I said last week, he is going to struggle to break tags with his lingering injury, so is one to stay away from.
- Michael Quinn: The young Irishman was a somewhat surprise inclusion (especially for owners of Howlett and Prismall who have had to put up with zeros due to their ‘poor disposal’), however he won’t be a surprise dropping for next weeks teams after an ordinary display.
- Michael Hurley: Played at full-forward but was kept scoreless by Rutten. 2010 has proven not to be his year, so I think it’s time we stopped holding our breath, waiting for him to come good.
Blip on the Radar:
- Andrew Welsh: Welsh has proven in previous seasons, and even in this one, that he is capable of the odd DT ton, but he has also proven (much more frequently) that he is capable of very low scoring in the 30-50 range. He may have scored well this week, but as a tagger, this is not what his game is based around.
Geelong vs North Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Paul Chapman: Straight back from injury and into the action was Chappy. Many coaches breathed a sigh of relief when he wasn’t a late withdrawal, then proceeded to jump for joy as he was the top scorer on-field. He finished with 37 disposals - most of which were by foot.
- James Podsiadly: After a shocker in the wet last week, Pods bounced back with his obligatory five goals at Skilled stadium. But what stood out about his game was not his goal kicking, but his forward pressure. He tackled and harassed all day, which would certainly have impressed the coach.
- Joel Corey: Corey has spent many weeks on the sidelines, so the expectation was that he would come back slowly. But, amazingly he didn’t, not only finishing with 27 disposals, but also an amazing 10 tackles. What is also worth noting is that his game percentage was a very low 75%, intimating that he is back to his ball-winning best.
Disappointing:
- Jack Ziebell: Unfortunately broke his leg very early in the game, ending his season. More sad injury news to another young rising star.
- Travis Varcoe: Maybe I have my sights set too high for Varcoe, but again he did much less than I expected of him. Only the one goal and 13 disposals whilst playing on the much slower Rawlings was a loss for Varcoe - perhaps don’t be taking my advice of a couple of weeks ago to trade him in.
- Lindsay Thomas: It seems that one amazing performance of a few weeks ago will be a once-off for Thomas. He spends too much time going for the freakish, rather than concentrating on the basics. He was penalised with a free against on a couple of occasions for going for speckies when he had no chance of marking the ball… This is proof why you don’t trade in a player after just one game!
Blip on the Radar:
- Matthew Scarlett: Scarlett is a reasonable rebounder, but is typically Geelong’s last line of defence, meaning he plays very deep. Occasionally he will rack up largish scores, as he did in this match, but it is not the norm. This score was thanks to him manning up on the resting ruckman - players very easy to run off, allowing him to pick up more ball across the half-back line.
Richmond vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Daniel Connors: Played up the ground and continues to push his game to new heights every time he steps on the football field. He racked up 26 touches and 10 marks whilst playing on O’Keefe and looks to have a lot of confidence in his own ability, which is great to see in such a young player.
- Ryan O’Keefe: O’Keefe is back in the good books after being seemingly out of form for a little while . He was back running through the midfield, clocking up 29 disposals, although it was his huge 11 tackles that really stood out on the stats sheet!
- Jude Bolton: Bolton played a fantastic game, especially in the first half as he really pushed Sydney to their strong lead. He is a great unheralded midfielder, although may be a little inconsistent to be pushing the elite category.
Disappointing:
- Tadhg Kennelly: Was shocking in his first game back from injury. He must be experiencing déjà-vu from when he played his last season of AFL - a year marred with injury and poor form after such a strong start. Now priced under $200k, all his owners will be baffled by their decision to stick with him!
- Ben Cousins: Ben is/was a great player, but at Richmond there are two issues - firstly, he is always the first tagged, and being in a young team he rarely gets support. Secondly, he simply loves to handball - his kick to handball ratio is so poor that even a 30 disposal game will likely see him fall short of the ton.
- Heath Grundy: ‘Reg’ had such a strong start to the year as an attacking defender, however this past month has seen him move back into a more defensive role, killing his DT ability in the process. Averaging just 66 points across the last five weeks, now may be the time to count your losses with him.
Blip on the Radar:
- Will Thursfield: In Thursfield’s 63 game career as a defender, his 96 DT points beat his previous best DT score by more than 30 points! He is strictly a dour defender, and games like this only happen every… well… 63 games I guess.
St.Kilda vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Clinton Jones: Was best on ground by my opinion - spent the first half tagging Davey out of the game, then was freed up to be a midfielder in his own right. He then proceeded to get his hands on just about every clearance and looked to get a whole new lease on his game. This won’t happen very often, however it was good for him to show Ross Lyon what he is capable of.
- Leigh Montagna: Joey just keeps running and running and presenting and presenting. He is such a hard worker and it is no surprise he is constantly racking up the dream team points. Even when the game is done and buried he is still working hard to win the ball.
- Brendon Goddard: Started forward and was the focal point of most of St.Kilda’s attacks. And although he cracked it that he wasn’t kicking enough goals of his own, he was still able to rack up plenty of the pill, finishing with 31 touches.
Disappointing:
- Tom Scully: Played all game on a HFF, which was strange and St.Kilda’s strong defence was able to shut him out of the game. I doubt this is a new role, but rather a way of resting him.
- James Gwilt: Played the best game of his career last week, and whilst again very good against the Dees, Jimmy didn’t rack up nearly the same amount of ball as his did then.
- Nathan Jones: Played the whole game as a tagger, as he has been all year, and it is obviously effecting his scoring.
Blip on the Radar:
- Kyle Cheney: This was his first game for the year, and whilst serviceable to a degree, his strength was his defensive work, not his rebounding. So if he does get another game, don’t be expecting too many dashing runs from defence to accompany it.
This post currently has
3 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on June 28th, 2010
This post currently has
8 comments ·
Add a comment
Don’t forget to check out the Weekly Wrap from week one of the split round!
Geelong vs St.Kilda:
Looking Good:
- Nick Dal Santo: Dal was let of the Ling leash for the first time in several years and he relished the freedom. He made the most of his lack of tag with 31 touches, 90% of which reached their target - a statistic that suggests that it is unlikely the Cats will allow him this much freedom next time they meet.
- Joel Selwood: Was the Cats best by a mile - his work in the clearances was sublime and he continued to work hard all evening, thriving in the wet, contested conditions. When he initially lined up on Hayes in the first quarter, I must admit I got a bit excited - unfortunately though it didn’t last too long.
- James Gwilt: Gwilt, although not quite making it to a DT ton, was the Saints best through the game with his great drive off half-back. His confidence was clearly up, as was his decision making skills, making him a very threatening player coming off the backline. Not only did he win 27 of his own disposals, but he also shut Podsiadly completely out of the match, keeping him goalless.
Disappointing:
- James Podsiadly: Pods had a night to forget, kicking no majors amongst his 7 disposals - easily his worst return of the year. Admittedly it wasn’t his ideal conditions, but he certainly let down plenty of dream teamers this week.
- Rhys Stanley: Stanley has been serviceable, if not good, in his handful of games this year, however his inclusion has been somewhat of a structural decision rather than one based on form. But now with the imminent return of Riewoldt, Stanley will likely find himself out of the squad - whilst he hasn’t done much to suggest he should be dropped, Lyon is unlikely to give such a young player much of a chance as his team approaches the finals.
- Travis Varcoe: If there is one type of player who can carve up St.Kilda, it is a speedy wingman with great acceleration and ball-handling skills. So it was surprising to see Varcoe given such a small role on the ball in this game, especially in the wet conditions. He should have been given the opportunity to rack up 25 disposals, but instead finished with just 11.
Blip on the Radar:
- Darren Milburn: Milburn is a DT veteran, and is still capable of providing a large score as proven in this game. However, at his age and in the role he predominantly plays in the Cats backline, don’t be expecting many huge scores out of him this year. It is always a huge risk bringing a player of Milburn’s vintage into your side, especially with few trades remaining.
Sydney vs Collingwood:
Looking Good:
- Darren Jolly: Played his best game of the year against his old side and clearly acted like he had something extra to play for. He finished with 17 possessions and was the dominant ruckman on the ground. I considered putting this game down as a blip on the radar due to his average form all year, but the hope can maybe be that this will be his breakout game in the white and black.
- Martin Mattner: Stepped up in the backline in the absence of Kennelly and the relatively low output of the heavily tagged Malceski. He played on Leigh Brown, but had obvious license to rebound, collecting 26 possessions, 7 tackles and 8 marks for the game.
- Heath Shaw: Thrived without any opposition, especially in the first half when Sydney allowed him to roam free as the loose man. He finally received some attention in the second half, but he had fortunately seen enough of the ball early to help himself to his first ton in a little while.
Disappointing:
- Adam Goodes: Was spanked by Presti and didn’t look like his usual attacking self. In Bradshaw’s absence he played closer to goal and this only helped Presti’s plight. Only finished with the 13 touches.
- Leon Davis: When Presti scores more Dream Team points than you, you know you’re in trouble! He started the game with spark, looking dangerous when the ball came in his area, but as soon as he had to do something with it, his confidence went out the window. A whopping five frees against didn’t help his scoring either.
- Daniel Hannebery: Was pretty poor against a quality opposition. Just had one of those games where he couldn’t get anywhere near it.
Blip on the Radar:
- Leigh Brown: Brown is a player who can come out and play one or two blinders a year, but has never proven himself as a consistent dream teamer, nor a consistent participant in the Collingwood side. Don’t ever get sucked into this guy, no matter how many good games he may play.
Adelaide vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Simon Goodwin: The Skipper played one of his better games of the season, running off the half-back line. This was the first time this year the Crows have really shown some consistent form, and if it continues, Goodwin’s form should hopefully continue as he plays out the final weeks of his career.
- Graham Johncock: When actually fit, Stiffy has played some very good games this year, and again his run off half-back was a highlight of the game. He racked up 32 disposals, and as he has proven time and time again, he is also capable of dropping forward for the odd goal.
- Tom Scully: This kid is going to be a star, and it is not hard finding parallels between him and Judd at the same age. His inside work is great for a first year player - he finished with 9 tackles for the game - just think of how good this kid will be in a few years!
Disappointing:
- Brad Miller: Stood by Rutten and did nothing all day, only contributing a solitary behind to the scoreboard. The Dees must be hoping Jurrah isn’t far away!
- Richard Douglas: Played on a forward flank, rather than in the midfield position that has won him plenty of DT fans in the past month or so. Unfortunately, he also chose to handball the footy much more than kicking it, meaning his reasonable 24 disposals only translated to an average 68 points.
- Jordie McKenzie: I don’t quite understand why McKenzie has fallen so quickly out of favour after a great start to the year - this week he was given a run-with role on Bernie Vince, but did a better job at shutting himself out of the contest, finishing with only 11 disposals.
Blip on the Radar:
- Bernie Vince: Vince played well - in fact he finished with 30 disposals and a goal, despite a tag. The worry is though, Neil Craig has blatantly announced that Vince is not 100% fit, and won’t be for the remainder of the year. Whilst he is currently very cheap, and is a very good player, the last thing you should do is trade an unfit player into your squad at this stage of the season. Not only could he miss more games, his game time will likely be down on his average, and he may even be made to sit out the last few games of the year when Adelaide concede that they won’t make finals. Consider him for 2011 instead.
This post currently has
8 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on June 21st, 2010
This post currently has
8 comments ·
Add a comment
Hawthorn vs Essendon:
Looking Good:
- Lance Franklin: The most talked about individual game of the weekend was Franklin’s, with his two amazing runs down the wing in the last quarter the highlights. He is looking so much more confident in his body and his form this year and could be a really good trade option for those with a weak forward line.
- Jobe Watson: Was especially influential in the second half when the game turned towards the Bombers, despite a tough tag from Sewell. Watson is working just as hard outside the contests these days and it is helping his DT scoring exponentially.
- Michael Osborne: Played more time through the midfield this week and played with plenty of spark through the four quarters. Was one of Hawthorn’s best in delivering the ball inside-50.
Disappointing:
- Michael Hurley: After a very good game last week, Hurley again failed to deliver much fire-power to the Dons. He does try very hard, and it must be remembered he is only in his second year, despite his great finish to 2009.
- Chance Bateman: Played a tagging role on Stanton and it killed his own scoring. He was also concussed in the last quarter, however strangely can’t remember how it happened.
- Luke Hodge: Took a knock to the knee early and it really slowed down his explosiveness. He was also heavily tagged by Welsh who gave him no room, despite the injury. The injury fortunately, doesn’t look serious enough to make him miss any games.
Blip on the Radar:
- Beau Muston: Those who saw the game would have been pretty impressed by Muston in his defensive forward role, but his score of 46 was a clear sign that he should not be a dream team target.
Fremantle vs Carlton:
Looking Good:
- Aaron Sandilands: When Kruezer was injured in the first quarter, big Sandi stepped it up a notch, dominating the much younger Sam Jacobs. He came one hitout short of the magical 50 mark, also clocking up 19 disposals and a bonus goal.
- Michael Barlow: Played more around the half-forward flanks, but it didn’t hinder his ball-winning abilities at all. He racked up another 30 possessions, as well as a very good four goals.
- Andrew Walker: Was one of the Blues best as a rebounder off the half-back line. He has been playing this role really well this year, and most importantly, consistently - he reached 27 disposals with 12 marks.
Disappointing:
- Heath Scotland: Second week in a row he has been down on form, only reaching 20 disposals, despite still playing through the midfield. The Blues had very little lift or form through the first three quarters and Scotland helped tell that tale.
- Alex Silvagni: Played in defence on Henderson and only had 6 disposals - his lowest of the year. He shouldn’t lose his spot, but the arrival of Roberton may take some of his kicks.
- Matthew Kruezer: Landed awkwardly in the first quarter and it was all bad news for the rising star - it was confirmed on Sunday that he has ruptured his ACL and will miss the remainder of the year.
Blip on the Radar:
- Garrick Ibbotson: In his 50th game, seemed to attract more ball than usual, playing in the backline. He plays shut-down roles these days, so occasional big scores like this one are more due to over-possessing the ball than a role change.
Brisbane vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- Jack Redden: It’s not surprising this kid has now played a couple of very good games in a row after a great breakout season in 2009. Unfortunately, it’s only been the past couple of weeks we have seen this promised form after a slowish start to the year. He is a great in-and-under players and looks to be one of the few Lions who are trying to lead a team quickly falling apart.
- Angus Graham: Has been thriving this past month as Richmond’s number one ruckman - once again he produced the goods, racking up 23 disposals and 12 marks for the game.
- Daniel Connors: In his second game back from suspension, Connors was again a highlight for the Tigers. He looks very dedicated to paying the club back after his earlier indiscretions and is certainly going the right way about it with a strong 23 possession game.
Disappointing:
- Brendan Fevola: In his 200th game, Fev had an absolute stinker. Despite being the target of 13 Brisbane inside-50s, he only capitalised with the one goal. In Vossy’s presser afterwards, strong intimations came that no-one was safe, even Fevola - if I were him I’d be pretty concerned about my spot in the team right about now.
- Trent Cotchin: He is a class player but just can’t handle the tag - this time, the attention of Sheldon kept him to just the 46 points.
- Ben Griffiths: I only had to bring it up as it is the first time (which I can remember) that this has happened - thanks to Griffith’s first three scores of 19, 15 and 19, could he be the first $89k player to go DOWN in price after his first three games??
Blip on the Radar:
- Matt White: White played well around the half-forward line, and he presents himself as a good player, but he currently looks much more like a player who will break out in 2011 than in the latter half of this year. In a young team and consistently thrown between roles, inconsistent scores can be expected.
Port Adelaide vs North Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Brent Harvey: Harvey was best afield for the Roos and Port had no answers for him, with neither Kane Cornes or Cassisi capable of shutting him down. Harvey is a top DT choice, however his main flaw is his ability to pull out the odd mega shocker - his ability to break the tag this week and the Roos good form are both good signs though!
- Jay Schulz: Booted seven goals as the most dominant forward on the ground. His form has been decent this year, but seven goals was totally out of the box from what we should typically expect of Schultz.
- Lachlan Hansen: Is starting to become accustomed to his new role up forward and his press in the papers didn’t seem to do him too badly either as he kicked five goals on Chad Cornes. I am still a sceptic, but he may not be as poor an option as I have originally suggested.
Disappointing:
- Lindsay Thomas: After his mega game last week, Thomas returned to his usual form with a standard 1.3 goals. Proof that you shouldn’t jump on a player after just one good game.
- Jackson Trengove: Second week in a row he has stunk it up now, which is unfortunate, as the past two weeks are about the only ones he will have been needed all season thanks to him covering for plenty of teams who have the injured Hille.
- Mitch Banner: Many were relieved to see him return, but a low game time saw him feature only a little in the stats. Only finished with the 15 disposals, well down on what he made us expect earlier in the year.
Blip on the Radar:
- Jacob Surjan: Surjan has been having a good year, but he is your typical tough-nut defender who does more one-percenters than he has disposals. In this game he held Lindsay Thomas tight and was allowed to run off him on occasion - something that won’t be allowed by his opponents too frequently this year.
Western Bulldogs vs West Coast:
Looking Good:
- Daniel Giansiracusa: Gia played a very good game again as a permanent forward, kicking two goals. He is still learning the role, but his leading up the flanks is getting stronger and he was the Bulldogs best player in the first half. Fortunately, he is also building on his consistency - something that has been queried so far this season.
- Beau Waters: Another strong game in the backline where he played loose man for the first three quarters. He drifts around and gets so much of the ball - he also uses it pretty well too so his teammates will continue to trust him with it. His role also sees him drifting into the midfield on occasions - his game could be well likened to Malceski or Duffield.
- Jarrod Harbrow: Played further afield thanks to the lack of Eagle small forwards and he played very well. However, I wouldn’t be expecting a permanent shift thanks to his great form to date as a defender.
Disappointing:
- Josh Kennedy: Just couldn’t exert any influence on the contest, only kicking the one goal through a good mark in the third term. Was very well held by Morris - also, the delivery from West Coast’s backline was shocking, certainly not helping his case.
- Brad Johnson: This was Johno’s first game back from an achilles injury and he certainly doesn’t look 100% - I predict a few DTers will look at Johnson’s price and get a bit excited, but already he has proven this year that he is no longer capable of the sort of scoring that was expected of him a few years ago. Also, his body can no longer be trusted.
- Barry Hall: When Jack Riewoldt kicked 10 goals against the WCE backline last week, Hall owners may have been excited about his prospects in this game. Unfortunately, he could only make it to three goals for the game.
Blip on the Radar:
- Will Schofield: Schofield played his game on both Lake and Johnson - two players who hate standing still and love venturing far away from their direct opponent, styles which allowed Schofield to be left alone plenty of times through the game and attract plenty of the ball as loose man. Whilst he is progressing well as a defender, he is not the right choice for dream team.
This post currently has
8 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on June 13th, 2010
This post currently has
11 comments ·
Add a comment
North Melbourne vs Carlton:
Looking Good:
- Lindsay Thomas: Played easily his personal best game of his career, and possibly even the best individual game of the season. He was brilliant throughout the full game, scoring himself stats across all lines; not only did he kick 7.5, he also got himself 20 touches, 8 marks and 8 tackles.
- Bryce Gibbs: Started the game again in the backline, however sense prevailed in the second term when Ratten moved him into the midfield. The move paid off with Gibbs being the best of Carlton’s mids. Hopefully this may pave the way for more midfield time in coming weeks.
- Jarrad Waite: In his second game back from suspension, Waite kicked three goals and looked reasonably dangerous as the key tall for Carlton. Looks capable of some consistent and high scoring.
Disappointing:
- Andrew Carrazzo: Once again, Carrots was given the key tagging job on Harvey, shutting down his own personal game in the process. This is now three weeks in a row where his game-style has been very negative, hurting his scoring in the process. If you have him, keep him and hope he comes good. If you are tempted by his low price, I wouldn’t risk it, as his role seems to change week to week.
- Lachlan Hansen: Up forward again and had very little effect on the game. He seems too set on annoying and sledging his opponents than actually playing the game - unfortunately this acts more negatively on him than anyone else…
- Jordan Russell: Moved onto the raging Thomas early (to little effect), but it prevented his run from defence. Should bounce back.
Blip on the Radar:
- Scott Thompson: Was a huge playmaker in defence, but his direct opponent was Waite, a player who plays much higher than Thompson’s regular opponents. This allowed him access to more ball as he played more around the half-forward line than in the square. Normally, Thompson will play on a full-forward, causing him to spend a lot of time away from ball-winning areas.
Hawthorn vs Adelaide:
Looking Delicious:
- Cyril Rioli: This was his first full game in the midfield this year and he simply dominated. Amongst his 27 touches he had 3 goals, 9 tackles and 7 marks. The fact he has finally built his tank to now play midfield is ominous to opposition teams, but simply ‘delicious’ to those looking at him for their dream team!
- Luke Hodge: It is going to be hard for the umpires to split the Brownlow votes as Hodgey was just as good as Cyril. He played the full game in the guts, racking up 32 disposals, three goals and 5 tackles. He is in incredible form at the moment and is looking like another player in the ‘untaggable’ category.
- Brad Symes: This was Symes’ first game for the season after an injury interrupted campaign to this point. He is a very capable ball-winner off the half-back line and can only get better as he builds his fitness. Keep an eye on him as a late-season smokey.
Disappointing:
- Brad Sewell: The attacking role played by Sewell last year seems to have now fallen by the wayside as he is now Hawthorn’s key tagger. He is continuing to leak points and is showing no signs of adding an attacking aspect to his game - avoid him, despite the tempting price.
- Jason Porplyzia: The Porpoise is clearly still lacking match fitness, although it does seem to be taking a long time to come to him. He managed no goals amongst his measly 8 disposals and 4 marks.
- Ivan Maric: The theme of 2010 has been that you can always trust a ruckman to chop against either of Hawthorn or Adelaide due to their lack of a key experienced ruck duo. Maric’s poor effort of just 4 disposals easily concluded that Adelaide has the unenviable title of ‘worst ruck duo’ in the AFL.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brent Reilly: We have seen Reilly play a tagging role this year, and typically he isn’t too bad at it. Unfortunately, in this game his direct opponent was Hodge, who completely dominated him. Lucky for Reilly though, Hodge paid him no attention the other way, allowing him to rack up 21 disposals for himself - don’t be expecting anything this exciting again this season.
Essendon vs Geelong:
Looking Good:
- Jimmy Bartel: Played an awesome game on the half-forward line in the absence of Mooney. His great marking ability and talent in-close helped him to 28 disposals, 8 marks and 3 goals. Should be back in the middle against the Saints next week, and just a little word of advice if you have him - make sure to make him captain; the game will be tough, in close and contested - he will eat it up!
- James Kelly: Played solely as a midfielder and was probably Geelong’s best mid for the game. He was solid across the four quarters and holds a very good work-rate. It’s a bonus that you can pick him up in the backline!
- James Podsiadly: He needs a special mention after clearly carrying a niggling groin injury into the game. In a week where several popular DT forwards couldn’t play (Brown, Sylvia, Higgins), it was great to see Pods tough it out. What’s more, he didn’t just play ok, but his fifth bag of five goals helped him again reach the ton!
Disappointing:
- Ricky Dyson: Just couldn’t provide any run from defence with Geelong’s fierce pressure. He is too outside a player to have much effect under the packs.
- Leroy Jetta: He loves it when Essendon are winning, but when they are down he seems to go missing. He is still young, so some inconsistency is acceptable.
- Paul Chapman: He didn’t do it by much - only by one point in fact! Do what? This is the first time Chappy didn’t make it to 100 DT points this season! Poor form by Chappy - I think everyone should trade him out this week! (NB: Probably worth stressing my sarcasm in the above comment before it comes back to bite me!).
Blip on the Radar:
- Alwyn Davey: He is not and never will be a dream team player. Fortunately for him in this game though, Geelong only have one true small defender and he was busy elsewhere, allowing Davey to be mismatched and kick a few goals.
Port Adelaide vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Nick Malceski: Was prolific off the Swans backline and set up almost all of their attacks. Kennelly’s return probably helps him as they do work well alongside each other. This score is probably a bit out of the box for him thanks to some late junk-stats, but he did earn a good percentage of his kicks by working hard, often getting two or three disposals per passage out of defence.
- Kane Cornes: Played his usual tagging job, as usual without much grandeur or excitement, but also as usual he racked up plenty of the ball. He wouldn’t have been in Port’s best three players (Hartlett, Thomas and Surjan), but just knows where to put himself to get a kick - a perfect attribute for your dream team!
- Ryan O’Keefe: O’Keefe was Sydney’s best midfielder in the first half, racking up 58 points to half time. Unfortunately, in the third and fourth quarter, Logan was moved onto him, virtually shutting him out of the game. With five minutes left on the clock, O’Keefe was on an average 72 points, before playing one of the most prolific games of kick-to-kick I have ever seen - a game which netted him (and his relieved owners) a whopping 38 points - gotta love that!
Disappointing:
- Jesse White: Was really well played by Carlile and simply couldn’t stick any marks. Got very frustrated with himself towards the end, but not nearly as frustrated as those that have him in their dream teams.
- Jackson Trengove: He needed to step up this week for all coaches playing him in the spot vacated by the injured Hille. Unfortunately he didn’t see very much of the ball - a lot of it was due to his teammates just not kicking it to him, despite the fact he was the main tall target up forward.
- Steven Salopek: Was off the field in the third quarter with a shoulder injury - unfortunately he now requires a shoulder reconstruction and will likely miss the rest of the season.
Blip on the Radar:
- Chad Cornes: His score of 77 suggests he wasn’t too bad, but those who saw the game will confirm he is still a long way off his best. He did get an OK amount of the ball, mainly playing in defence, but he generally used it poorly and gave away a couple of key free-kicks. He will continue to have his spot in the team questioned by the coaching staff, so stay away from him, regardless of how cheap he gets!
Richmond vs West Coast:
Looking Good:
- Jack Riewoldt: Jack was brilliant and the first player of the year to kick a ten goal haul, including five in the first term alone. He was brilliant all day and is really proving a consistent forward target who even the best defenders will have a hard day on. With the lack of other options, a different ‘Riewoldt’ to usual may find himself named in the All-Australian team if he keeps this form up.
- Beau Waters: Played again on the half-forward line, continuing his brilliant recent form. He plays a forward tagging role, but unlike other defensive forwards, Waters hurts his opponents through disposal - not by sitting on them. WCE will continue to play through Waters to get into the forward line in an attempt to force his opponent to man up.
- Brett Deledio: Waters’ direct opponent, and the man he was trying to shut down was Deledio. Deledio clearly ignored Waters and continued to go about his business as a rebounding defender as normal. He’s is in some good form and this role really suits him. I still worry a bit about picking premium players from teams on the bottom of the ladder, but Lids could be a good pick regardless.
Disappointing:
- Nic Naitanui: Nic-Nat is starting to slow down as the season progresses, forcing him to have more time in the forward line than on the ball (the improved fitness of Cox doesn’t help his case). Is probably in line for a rest in the coming weeks.
- Ben Griffiths: I’ll start by saying that I’m not slagging off the kid at all - but I just wanted to say that he probably isn’t a viable option for your bench at this stage of his career. His 15 points won’t be too out of place with other scores he should get this year - as he is a key forward he will take a while to adjust to the pace and ferocity of the game.
- Shannon Hurn: Was sat on by Jake King and wasn’t allowed too much influence out of the backline. These sort of scores shouldn’t be too uncommon for Hurn though as he doesn’t need too many disposals to influence a game.
Blip on the Radar:
- Bradd Dalziell: Unfortunately, Triple-D isn’t back to his ball-winning ways from Brisbane, but just played a big part in the late junk-time stats. After a great first year he has really dropped away in the DT stakes and shouldn’t be considered for your team.
Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane:
Looking Good:
- Barry Hall: Six goals on the still unfit Merrett was a good return for the big man. After talks of him being rested in coming weeks it was good to see him hit back, although he is very likely to back this up with a poor game next week as has been his form-line this year.
- Tom Rockliff: This was Rockliff’s third ton in a row and he did it running through the middle with an incredible kick to handball ratio - he kicked it 19 times to only 6 handballs - an incredible effort!
- Adam Cooney: Continuing his good recent form with another strong game - 30 disposals and 7 tackles. He still comes cheap and could be worth considering for your last midfield spot.
Disappointing:
- Brendan Fevola: Didn’t (or perhaps couldn’t) step up in Brown’s absence and was very poor, kicking just the two goals from 6 possessions.
- Travis Johnstone: After being DT’s top scorer last week, he played a much more defensive role this week on Giansiracusa. Did very little rebound work as Gia was one of the Dog’s main forward targets for the game.
- Brodie Moles: Couldn’t get into the game, despite the Dogs dominance. Many will be hoping he can keep his spot in the team, despite the sub-par performance.
Blip on the Radar:
- Mitch Hahn: Hahn is a decent player and can rack up a decent DT score, but is incredibly inconsistent. He has also been in below-average form this year, giving further reasons to why you don’t want him.
Fremantle vs St.Kilda:
Looking Good:
- Brendon Goddard: Another best-on-ground performance from Goddard. He spent the first three quarters as the loose man in defence, mopping up every Fremantle attack. He moved into the midfield in the last quarter and Freo simply couldn’t quell his influence.
- Michael Barlow: This kid won’t stop! He doesn’t just rack up stacks of the ball, but he plays the game incredibly well too - he finds space, works really hard, tackles well and uses the ball smartly.
- Sam Gilbert: His rebound from defence was amazing - he runs with such creativity, but also with incredible boldness, often taking on tackles and packs, and often getting away.
Disappointing:
- Byron Schammer: His first game for the year and chances are it’s his last too. Had very little effect on the game, being left in the forward line for large chunks. All the kids have overtaken him and would likely have much more upside than him too.
- Sam Fisher: Without Dawson (who should be back next week), Fisher was forced to a defensive role of Pavlich (and did very well, keeping him to just one goal). Unfortunately, this quelled his ability to run from defence.
- Leigh Montagna: Was heavily tagged by Crowley and didn’t handle it particularly well, although he did continue to work hard all day. Was knocked unconscious by Mundy’s knee in a marking attempt early in the fourth term and he played no further part in the game.
Blip on the Radar:
- Robert Eddy: Played his best game for the year in the forward line, and finally looked to be marking and disposing of the ball with more confidence. Unfortunately, his spot in the team is the one which is regularly rotated at the Saints between himself, Jack Steven, Nick Heyne and Tom Lynch (yet to debut). Also, with Riewoldt, Gram, Dawson and Armitage all due back within the next four weeks, spots will become very tight at the Saints.
Collingwood vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Brent Moloney: Moloney was best afield in the first draw of the season, and was especially influential in the last quarter when the Dees crawled back in front, albeit momentarily. Is in red hot form at the moment and with Melbourne’s current form, he wouldn’t be such a bad option.
- Dane Swan: The disposal king racked them up again, finishing with 38 touches, plus 7 marks and 7 tackles. Unfortunately, his score could have been even better if his three shots at goal hadn’t all missed.
- Scott Pendlebury: Carried on from his BOG performance last week with another great game. Pendlebury has typically been a Supercoach specialist, however over the past few months is beginning to show more DT ability with an increase in marks and tackles.
Disappointing:
- Heath Shaw: Had only two points to his name at half time which was terrible - his inconsistency seems to be continuing. He played a defensive role on Dunn which prevented him from doing much rebound work.
- Jordan Gysberts: The most traded in player of the week was the second-lowest scorer of the game (in front of only Presti!). His low ten disposals and lack of tackles may worryingly put his place in the team under some pressure - especially with Macdonald due back soon.
- Leon Davis: Played up forward to little effect, only gaining the one goal. He does look good in bursts but it is where he is being played that is effecting him. However, with the returns of Dick and Lockyer (moreso Dick), Davis may find he does get put further up ground in the coming weeks.
Blip on the Radar:
- Tarkyn Lockyer: This was Lockyer’s fifth game of the year after being dropped for round five. Whilst Malthouse claims that Lockyer is still in his plans - and the fact he played well will help - I still would have worries about trading a player like Lockyer, who clearly has poor job security, into my team. Don’t be sucked in by his big score, as it is not necessarily his ball-winning ability that is keeping him out of the team!
This post currently has
11 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on June 7th, 2010
This post currently has
31 comments ·
Add a comment
St.Kilda vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- Brendon Goddard: Was the architect of the Saints wins - his 38 disposals came all over the ground as the Tigers were unable to shut him down. Possibly his best game of the year!
- Jack Riewoldt: Riewoldt was sensational and almost looked like getting the Tigers over the line with some amazing plays in the third quarter. He amazingly seemed too strong and too agile at ground level for his veteran opponents, Sam Fisher and Jason Blake (who even double-teamed him for a while, yet still to no avail!).
- Raph Clarke: The often maligned, often criticised half-backer from St.Kilda looks to be coming into some reasonable DT form over the past couple of weeks. He is regularly left free by the opposition thanks to his penchant for turnovers, allowing him to plenty of the ball. He could be an inconsistent option, but for his current price does present as reasonable value.
Disappointing:
- Robert Eddy: I still am unsure why he gets a game - he does work hard, but can’t kick, can’t mark and regularly goes to ground.
- Adam Schneider: Hungry, hungry, hungry. Those with Hayes in their team would have cursed Schneids as he attempted to mark a Hayes goal, only to just get a finger on it, causing a rushed behind… This was not his only hungry effort - in fact, if a possession doesn’t end with a goal at the moment for Schneids, then it’s a possession not worth having. Needs to play the team game or have a run in the VFL.
- Mitch Morton: Had only two opportunities to kick a goal (and surprise, surprise he played on and missed) and didn’t get much else done for the game.
Blip on the Radar:
- Stephen Milne: Milney was at his best on Friday night, kicking 5 goals as the Saints leading forward target. Whilst he missed all of his set shots, his kicks on the run and dribbling from the boundary were brilliant! He has become a better player in Riewoldt’s absence, but he is still one for inconsistency. He rarely plays well interstate or in big games, however in his 200th game next week, look for another bag from the little man.
Carlton vs Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Jarrad Waite: Kicked three goals as a CHF and looks really suited to the position. As one of Carlton’s few tall marking targets in the forward half, the ball does end up in his hands a bit and he finished with 10 marks.
- Ryan Houlihan: Really started Carlton’s surge with 3 goals in the first half and kept presenting. The only worry is that he only scored 90 points in a near BOG performance…
- Colin Sylvia: Whilst still not quite where we want him to be, he is looking a bit better, although still playing on a forward flank. He does present well upfield and his tackling is a strength - hopefully his form can both can continue and improve.
Disappointing:
- Bryce Gibbs: After a huge week last week, he was relegated to a tagging job on Green which really makes no sense - why play one of your best playmakers as a stopper!? I don’t understand Ratten sometimes - and it now seems Gibbs cannot be trusted regularly for a good score, just like Carrazzo.
- Jack Watts: Only the one goal this week - he looks good in fits and bursts and will come good eventually - nothing better than a bench option for you at the moment unfortunately.
- Brad Miller: The main reason Watts will remain in the team is because of the poor contribution from senior players such as Miller. The effects of his big bag a couple of weeks ago may have worn off now, possibly paving way for the return of Newton or Hughes.
Blip on the Radar:
- Cameron Bruce: This is probably one of the bigger calls, as Bruce is arguably still a very good DTer. However, the role of senior players in the Melbourne squad seems very speculative at the moment, and a player like Bruce is not unlikely to be stuck in a back-pocket for a few games, killing his DT scoring. Despite his ability to score well I would still avoid him, thanks the fact he could turn sour any week.
Adelaide vs Fremantle:
Looking Good:
- Scott Thompson: Really carried his team in the midfield, especially in the third quarter. He hasn’t been as damaging recently as in previous years, so hopefully this game could represent a turn of form for him.
- Michael Barlow: Came back from injury with style, racking up 32 disposals and kicking a bonus three goals. Palmer is the still getting the most attention from taggers, allowing Barlow to rack up the ball free of any attention.
- Graham Johncock: Dominated on Ballantyne (until he fired up in the last quarter) and played a great rebounding game, whilst also dropping forward on a couple of occasions. Looks in good form after his injury and suspension and appears to be pretty good value.
Disappointing:
- Adam McPhee: Played at full-forward and did very little except for fall over. Showed some form in the past two weeks, but is clearly now back to his old ways.
- Kurt Tippett: Not surprisingly, Tarrant did a number on him, allowing him to only the one goal. He looked much fitter against the Saints last week, so surely his best isn’t far off.
- Jason Porplyzia: Well held by Duffield and was hardly sighted - he even missed a set-shot, which is totally unlike him. He may be cheap at the moment, but doesn’t look any good.
Blip on the Radar:
- Tyson Edwards: Played a brilliant last game, but unfortunately it was just that - his last game. Goodbye to one of the greater Dream Team players of the past decade!
North Melbourne vs Brisbane:
Looking Good:
- Tom Rockliff: Stepped up in the second half with the rest of the team and seemed to be everywhere, racking up 29 touches for the game. After two tons in a row, questions will begin to be asked about where this kid sits in everyone’s teams - is he still first emergency, or does one of the underperforming premiums get the flick?
- Andrew Swallow: Found himself under every pack through the game, and whilst only touching the ball 21 times, his 7 tackles and two goals really buffered his score. He was a big reason for the Roos win.
- Travis Johnstone: Johnstone spent plenty of time steaming off the backline, playing just the kind of footy he loves - uncontested. Plenty of kick-to-kick games did buffer his score, although he did work hard for plenty of his 37 disposals and 16 marks.
Disappointing:
- Ash McGrath: After I put the weight of the DT world on his shoulders the past two weeks, he succumbed to a hamstring injury in the second quarter. Bugger.
- David Hale: Did nothing. Maybe just a little bit? No - nothing.
- Jared Brennan: Vossy was spruiking before the match “I got Brennan back a week early from his ankle injury!” But what he meant to say was “I got Brennan back a week TOO early…” Was clearly underdone and performed accordingly!
Blip on the Radar:
- Lachlan Hansen: Played the game out at full-forward and looked OK, but nothing amazing. The last thing you want to do at this time of year is trade ANOTHER inconsistent performer into your team.
West Coast vs Geelong:
Looking Good:
- Beau Waters: Mark, kick, mark kick, etc. This was pretty much Beau’s game - not that I’m complaining in the slightest, but he played on a HFF and was treated to plenty of marks and then kicks before the ball entered the Eagle’s forward-50.
- Paul Chapman: Was the main driver for the Cats and one of their only consistent performers across the four quarters. He finished with 32 disposals for the game, but hardly tackled which was disappointing. And still, he hasn’t scored below 100 once this season.
- Jimmy Bartel: It wasn’t his type of game, but still he played reasonably through the midfield. He did actually produce a lot of turnovers, but at least continues to win the hard ball and tackle hard - all we ask of him for dream team.
Disappointing:
- James Podsiadly: Had a game to forget - firstly, he didn’t kick his mandatory five goals, then he got reported for an errant elbow and also seemed to injure his groin late in the game. We will now be watching how his week unfolds closer than usual.
- Scott Selwood: Needs to learn from his brother (Adam that is - Troy wouldn’t help…) the art of winning his own ball whilst also shutting down an opponent. Moved to Gary when Adam was injured it and hardly touched it after.
- Cameron Mooney: Rolled his ankle early on and struggled for the rest of the game with only 6 disposals and no goals.
Blip on the Radar:
- David Wojcinski: Wojo’s game is perfectly suited to Subi - in fact, if he played for West Coast or Fremantle he could be a much better player. But unfortunately, he only plays on the wide ground twice a year, and in between those two games he does very little in many other games. He is a pure impact player and does very little in the DT department.
Sydney vs Essendon:
Looking Good:
- Jude Bolton: Played off Watson and had a stellar game, not only racking up 36 disposals, but laying 12 tackles too. He is a great grunt-work player and this game really suited him.
- Shane Mumford: Is fast becoming one of the better tap-ruckman in the league, finishing with over 40 tap-outs for the second week in a row. He is beginning to look very consistent and could be a great mid-priced option for those in the market for a ruckman.
- Patrick Ryder: Only the 12 possessions, but worked hard across the ground, laying 7 tackles and having two shots on goal. Is capable of stepping up if Hille misses with his hamstring injury.
Disappointing:
- David Hille: After a terrible start with a statless first quarter, he went down with a hamstring injury part way through the second, killing plenty of coaches chances of victory with a measly 10 points.
- Daniel Hannebery: After a BOG performance last week, he was rather ineffective this week with only 11 disposals. He is still my pick for rising star, but up and down form is to be expected from a kid of only 19 years.
- David Myers: There was a lovely interview with Myers in the Sunday Herald Sun where he talked up his newfound consistency and spot in the team - unfortunately he might have spoken too soon, only clocking up 6 handballs and 2 tackles for the game.
Blip on the Radar:
- Mark McVeigh: Whilst ‘Spike’ did step up with rebounding duties in this game and even drifted forward for a goal, he has already proven this year that his role is not typically an attacking one, being stuck deep in defence on a small forward. He may be cheap, but this game is simply a trap!
Hawthorn vs Port Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Luke Hodge: Played up forward this week (just to change things up!) and kicked 1.5, which was slightly disappointing (just imagine if he’d kicked straight!). He did make up for it with an otherwise great game with 26 disposals and 10 marks by the end of the game.
- Travis Boak: Boak is fast becoming Port’s best player and had his skills on display, nearly giving enough to win the game for Port. He, like the rest of his teammates, has taken tackling to a new level, finishing with 11 himself for the game.
- Domenic Cassisi: Cassisi started with a bang, racking up a whopping five tackles in the first three minutes of play! He ended the game on 14 with 20 disposals to go alongside it.
Disappointing:
- Chad Cornes: Another game up forward for the veteran where he had no effect on the game. It couldn’t even be said he played a defensive forward game as his direct opponent Guerra had 24 disposals.
- Clinton Young: After an injury plagued 2009, Young was finally coming into some form before he injured his quad in the second quarter - he may spend several weeks on the sidelines to recover.
- Matthew Broadbent: After I talked his game up last week, he did very little in this one. Perhaps he is a wet weather specialist, or perhaps he is just inconsistent.
Blip on the Radar:
- Rick Ladson: We have had 11 rounds of football in 2010 to see that Ladson is not going to reach his 2008 level. A role as a midfield tagger and a couple of goals helped his score this week, but I wouldn’t be counting on it too frequently.
Collingwood vs Western Bulldogs:
Looking Good:
- Scott Pendlebury: Won the medal for best on ground in a solid four-quarter performance. He didn’t do anything incredible, but stuck to his job, even when the Dogs pressed late. The Dogs didn’t give him much of an opponent which helped.
- Matthew Boyd: Was huge in the last quarter when the Dogs made their unsuccessful press and finally looked back into some ball-winning form. He combines very well with Cooney in the middle, and if this last quarter was anything to go by, the Dogs might finally have re-found their kicking boots.
- Alan Didak: Was great all game, but especially early. This is one of the first times this year where Didak has really broken a tag. He only looked effected by Picken when he drifted forward and seemed on his own for great lengths of the game.
Disappointing:
- Shaun Higgins: Spent most of the game having his dodgy ankle worked on by the medical staff, meaning he was on and off the ground every five minutes. He finally succumbed in the last quarter and played no further part.
- Daniel Giansiracusa: Played a forward tag on Heath Shaw and saw very little of the ball. I was more disappointed that he wasn’t moved up the ground when Higgins went down with injury - his scoring as a forward this year has been less than ordinary.
- Paul Medhurst: This was his first game back from injury and he was poor - Leon finally fired as the small forward and Medhurst saw very little ball coming his way. May get better, but if you’re waiting for him to dominate a game you may be waiting a while.
Blip on the Radar:
- Will Minson: Played more as a permanent forward than usual and took a couple of decent marks. However, inconsistency has plagued Minson’s career, so don’t expect a turnaround now. Look to Mumford if you want a mid-priced ruck.
This post currently has
31 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on May 31st, 2010
This post currently has
29 comments ·
Add a comment
Essendon vs Western Bulldogs:
Looking Good:
- Paddy Ryder: The Essendon big men are on fire at the moment, with Ryder the main beneficiary this week. Unlike plenty of other ruckmen, his ability to drop forward is a real strength of his game, leading him to not only get plenty of ball around the ground, but also kick a few goals.
- Ben Hudson: Huddo has been in some pretty good form over the past couple of weeks and has a habit of always cutting sick against the Bombers. He is really strong around the ground and in the air, meaning his teammates regularly go to him for the bail-out kick.
- Brent Stanton: After a couple of off weeks, Stanton looked back at his best with a much better game through the middle. He was tagged, yet willed himself through it - and although his disposal still isn’t anything amazing, he gets plenty of it, and at the end of the day that’s all that matters!
Disappointing:
- Jason Akermanis: Looked like he would fit in much better in an EJ Whitten tribute game than in AFL football. Looked slow and emotionally drained. His career looks suddenly headed for the gurgler, so if you have him, now is the time to offload him!
- Nathan Lovett-Murray: After playing some great attacking football through the midfield before his injury, he returned only to be played as a tagger. He was effective, but this role won’t help his dream team ability.
- Ryan Hargrave: After starting the game really well as the loose man, he disappeared from site and did very little for the second half. Inconsistency seems to be his middle name at the moment.
Blip on the Radar:
- Leroy Jetta: Jetta ventured much higher up the field to not only rack up the ball, but also drop forward for some goals. He does look very lively, but does seem very likely to be an inconsistent type. I would want to see another game like this before I brought him in.
Western Bulldogs vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Gary Ablett: 32 disposals and a lazy 2 goals whilst resting up forward is beginning to be a standard day at the office for Ablett. He appears to hate negative press, so the more the media slag him off about Gold Coast, the more he appears to prove them wrong.
- Jordan Gysberts: In his debut game for Melbourne he was the highest disposal winner for the club with 26 touches. He played the game beautifully and showed no signs of being star-struck by the stars at Geelong - he went about his business like he’d been doing it for years.
- James Podsiadly: Another five goals from Pods was a brilliant effort from a guy we all paid roundly $77k for only a couple of months ago. I think we just wish he had been playing the game for longer!
Disappointing:
- Jack Watts: After all the big press the kid has gotten this week it was a shame to see him fade away against the Cats. In his defence, he was competing against a very strong Cats backline and therefore had very few chances to score. There is little chance he won’t bounce back.
- Jimmy Bartel: When you look at your team on Friday night and see Geelong vs Melbourne at Skilled Stadium in the wet, there is little hesitation in making Bartel captain, expecting a lazy 130 points from the good man. Unfortunately this was not to be as he was tagged out of the game by Grimes and wasn’t even allowed to junk it up in the last quarter… fair to say he was the reason behind a few eliminated teams this week!
- Austin Wonaeamirri: Still looks like he is regaining fitness from his time on the sidelines. Please remember he was never really a DT star before you get tempted and trade him in for the cash!
Blip on the Radar:
- James Frawley: Has a great knack of marking from opposition kicks, but he rarely ventures far out of his defensive-50. He will get occasional scores like this from kicking around in the backline, but he is not an attacking defender, so is not what you want.
Port Adelaide vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- Jack Riewoldt: For those that didn’t see this game, it was played in torrential rain and hence a mud-strewn football field - an environment very anti tall players. However, I thought that Riewoldt was once again one of Richmond’s best, kicking 4 goals and laying 7 tackles - great numbers for a guy of his size in this weather!
- Angus Graham: 14 tackles from a ruckman would have to be one of the bigger numbers in a long time. He keeps trying, and looked good as the Tiger’s number one big guy.
- Matthew Broadbent: First game for the season and looked composed. He has put some muscle on his body and looks to fit in well, running out of defence. He will get better in cleaner conditions, but he would be one of the few Port positives from this game.
Disappointing:
- David Rodan: Lacked the ability to inject much magic into the match thanks to the mud that kept bogging him down.
- Jeromey Webberley: Seemed to always be one step behind the ball and appeared nowhere near it in the second half. In only his fourth game, he shouldn’t worry about his near future in the side.
- Danyle Pearce: Was again tagged out of the match, but the weather wasn’t kind to a player who relies on his pace. Has been down a couple of weeks now which is a worry.
Blip on the Radar:
- Josh Carr: He would have licked his lips when he saw the weather forecast for this game. Carr is a hard-nosed midfielder, normally assigned tagging jobs, but he seemed to be given more of an attacking license in this game due to the conditions suiting him - don’t look for too much more of this in the future.
Brisbane vs Collingwood:
Looking Good:
- Luke Power: Creamed Collingwood through the middle in his 250th match. He doesn’t play at all like his age (in a good way) and is appearing in some pretty good form. Could be a pretty good alternative pick for your midfield.
- Dale Thomas: I think this is his highest DT score ever, further proving that 2010 is his breakout year. He finished the game with 34 disposals and 12 marks, playing exclusively as a midfielder. Possibly a bit expensive now, but is looking like a good consistent option for once!
- Ash McGrath: As predicted in my Tuesday article (blowing my own horn? Never!), McGrath’s rebounding role continued in very good fashion this week. He ran off the backline and minded Beams as he drifted forward.
Disappointing:
- Heath Shaw: STILL cannot handle a tag! Brisbane rotated men through him and he had no way of getting away. His highs can be fantastic, but Shaw is one of the most inconsistent dream teamers in the league!
- Dayne Beams: Beams has been in ripping form over the past few weeks, but was totally shut down by McGrath. Expect him to bounce back, but games like this should be expected with him playing more forward of centre.
- Brendan Fevola: Was well held by Presti in the first half, but when he moved further upfield to CHF he looked a lot better. 4 late goals saved his owners complete heartache, but his injury is clearly playing a part in his poor form.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brent Staker: Played plenty of kick-to-kick deep in the Brisbane backline, bellying his score. Brisbane love to over-possess the ball down back, but Staker is not a regular there, he is typically a forward. He has shown some good form this year, but he hasn’t enough improvement in him to be a worthwhile cash cow.
St.Kilda vs Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Leigh Montagna: Was sublime all game, kicking five brilliant goals amongst his 38 possessions. He has an amazing ability to find space and deliver the ball into the forward line, causing him to be given so much of the ball by his teammates. He is still very cheap for what he offers, so strongly consider!
- Richard Douglas: Douglas was easily the best Crow and set up plenty of their attacks from the midfield. Seven tackles highlighted his effort. I have been very critical of Douglas over the journey, but he could prove to be the Bernie Vince of 2010.
- Sam Fisher: Ahem… As some Tuesday article suggested, Fisher’s return to the backline repaid with some great scoring. He got 12 disposals in the first term alone and went on to finish with 30. He takes plenty of marks and constantly rotates with Gilbert as the loose man.
Disappointing:
- Andrew McLeod: Shut down by Baker, a strong nemesis from years gone by. He saw very little of the ball (maybe he was emotional about the retiring of his good friend Tyson Edwards), but to his credit he did come into the game under an injury cloud.
- Justin Koschitzke: The delivery wasn’t amazing to Kosi, but he didn’t help himself by continually leading to the wrong spots and dropping marks. Looks bereft of confidence and perhaps needs a run in the ruck to wake him up.
- Taylor Walker: I actually hadn’t even realised Walker was playing until I saw his name on the goals sheet. Was well held by Blake and Gwilt, but did very little to work through this.
Blip on the Radar:
- Steven Baker: Nowadays, Baker is typically a stay-home defender, playing on the opponent’s best small forwards. However, he moved into the midfield for this game to play on McLeod - a player he has a fantastic history on. This happens VERY rarely, so these sorts of scores are not to be expected.
Hawthorn vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Dan Hannebery: Those who have already given the Rising Star to Naitanui have clearly not watched any Sydney games! This kid showed some great signs last year and is already following through with his promises in spades this year! Played another best-on-ground performance with 25 disposals and 3 goals.
- Jordan Lewis: One of Hawthorn’s more consistent players (They seemed to share the load very evenly) - he has really bounced back since his dropping a few weeks ago - in fact, he hasn’t scored under 100 since!
- Shane Mumford: Mummy smashed Renouf in the ruck with 42 hitouts to 16 in a dominant display. He is also working very hard around the ground, racking up 17 disposals - I’m sure Geelong would wish their time over again with him!
Disappointing:
- Jarryd Roughead: Kicked no goals, again looking very uninterested. Hawthorn are just lucky that Buddy was able to step up in his place!
- Matt O’Dwyer: O’Dwyer was recalled to the seniors after a whopping 54 disposals last week in the reserves. Unfortunately, 11 touches was a little below par.
- Ryan O’Keefe: Played the entire game as a forward - a very worrying sign. Whilst O’Keefe used to be a good dream teamer as a forward, his days as a midfielder are much much better! Whether this is permanent, or he is just resting an injury will be a hotly discussed question this week!
Blip on the Radar:
- ?: I looked through this list and couldn’t find one high score where I thought “yeah… that’s not gonna happen again.” Let me know if you think otherwise!
Carlton vs West Coast:
Looking Good:
- Bryce Gibbs: Dominated off half-back with a whopping 45 possessions and 12 marks! This is what we want to see from Gibbs more often - his disposal was amazing, so it is no wonder Carlton are playing him behind the ball - he just needs to consistently deliver now!
- Chris Judd: Once again Judd proved untaggable and also a very good DT prospect in the process. He does enjoy beating up of his old side and this game was no exception. Various players were rotated through him, yet none seemed capable of slowing him down.
- Marc Murphy: 36 disposals seemed like nothing compared to Gibbs, but Murphy was just as impressive - despite an attempted tag, he still got the ball at will and laid 5 tackles in the process. The Blue boys are all looking like very good prospects at the moment.
Disappointing:
- Andrew Carrazzo: As the worry tends to be with Carrazzo, he was moved into the forward line for a tagging role and it in turn killed his scoring output. Whilst I’d like to say this is a one off, he does seem to be a player regularly thrown into different positions - some great of DT, and others just rubbish.
- Brad Ebert: Has been in super form this year, but just couldn’t get into this game, finishing with a measly 13 disposals.
- Scott Selwood: Was running though the midfield as a tagger, but didn’t bother trying to get it himself. He is apparently capable as a ball-winner, although we are yet to see it at AFL level.
Blip on the Radar:
- Jeff Garlett: Small forwards like Garlett are notoriously inconsistent. In free-flowing open games like this one, he will dominate. But put him into an ugly slog of a game and he will be lucky to make 50 points.
Fremantle vs North Melbourne:
Looking Good:
- Paul Duffield: Started slow, but as usual plenty of passages involving 4 or 5 disposals saw him become the highest scorer on the ground. He does know how to get into space beautifully, often seeing him part of Freo’s kick-to-kick sessions.
- Nathan Fyfe: This kid is unreal - he looks like a 15 year old boy, but plays with incredible maturity and flair! He was everywhere in the third quarter and ended up racking up 27 disposals and 3 goals for the game.
- Kepler Bradley: Maybe, just maybe this could be Bradley’s year. He has played three games so far and all have been impressive, although none as much as this one. He booted four goals as a forward and floated though the midfield as the second ruckman in parts too. As odd as it sounds - consider him.
Disappointing:
- Brent Harvey: He did get injured, however it wasn’t until ¾ time that he was off the field. Was well tagged by Van Berlo and had no effect on the game.
- Chris Mayne: He seemed to spend the game just floating around the packs, not actually touching the ball himself. Kicked a couple of goals, but it didn’t get much more exciting than that for the man with the giant schnoz.
- Michael Barlow: His late withdrawal saw over 160,000 dream team coaches seeing red. But let’s be honest - being the most un-unique player in the competition, it didn’t have too much effect anyway.
Blip on the Radar:
- Nathan Grima: Played a key defensive role on Pavlich, but was able to zone off thanks to Pav’s time in the middle. It meant for plenty of cheap ball he wouldn’t really get otherwise.
This post currently has
29 comments ·
Add a comment
By Toby on May 24th, 2010
This post currently has
20 comments ·
Add a comment
Geelong vs Collingwood:
Looking Good:
- Jimmy Bartel: This was always going to be a game he would thrive in and he did exactly that - his work under the packs was fantastic, but what separates Bartel from other midfielders is his ability above his head - he finished with 7 marks for the game - very good for an inside midfielder.
- James Kelly: Kelly lined up on the wing in a best on ground display. He showed a lot of poise and class for a player who had missed the prior week with injury and now looks in some great form. It is also great that you can pick him as a defender after playing roles back there in 2009.
- Corey Enright: This was Enright’s second strong rebounding game in a row as he worked hard off Didak. He has the ability to push high through the midfield, as well as drop back to play kick-to-kick with Scarlett - awesome for dream team. Like the Cats, he is coming into some super form and he has always been a consistent scorer, so jump on board!
Disappointing:
- Leon Davis: Another big game and once again, Davis did nothing. He finished the game with 9 disposals and one behind - very, very poor for a player with his capabilities. Stay well away from him in 2010!
- Chris Dawes: After some super recent form, Dawes was easily beaten by Taylor and Lonergan. He did try hard, but the delivery was well below par.
- Tom Hawkins: Hawkins had a super first half, but faded in the second. He is actually looking in some good form as he is rotated through the ruck, but he is still lacking that consistency which is preventing him from taking the leap from good to great. He could be a great 2011 option though.
Blip on the Radar:
- Nick Maxwell: Maxwell is very good at playing behind the ball and taking plenty of marks and kicks, but the irregularities of his game mean that he is far from a consistent dream teamer. Some weeks he will play much tighter on his man, leading to some very hyperactive scoring.
Western Bulldogs vs Sydney:
Looking Good:
- Brian Lake: Lake’s 192 points was the 6th best dream team game in recordable history - not too bad at all for the few that own him! It was a classic kick-mark-kick-mark-etc game as he played off the first gamer, O’Keefe. Lake will typically only average half of this, so don’t get too excited…
- Adam Cooney: Looked back at his browlow best, winning possessions and clearances at will. Take note though, Cooney is typically more of a SuperCoach player than DT, however he does win enough of the ball to clock up the ton a few times!
- Ryan Hargrave: YAAAAY!!! Finally, after ‘apparently’ bottoming out a few weeks ago, Hargrave has finally bounced back with a great game off half back - he was loose man alongside Lake and together they did as the pleased.
Disappointing:
- Sam Wright: One touch in the first half and five in the second sum up his efforts - it’s probably time he headed back to Werribee to find some form.
- Barry Hall: Was reported twice against Scott Thompson and despite each time being provoked, Barry is every chance to be gone for at least a couple of weeks with his record. Wasn’t in amazing form either…
- Matt Campbell: Campbell has proven to be one of the biggest NAB cup teases of the year - average for a few games before being dropped, and now that he is back, all he could conjure up was five touches, equalling the game’s lowest score of 29.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brian Lake: … Don’t be expecting 192 every week!
Sydney vs Fremantle:
Looking Good:
- David Mundy: Despite coming into the game under an injury cloud, Mundy proved to be one of the most pivotal players for Freo. His precise kicking is a feature of his game and his teammates constantly deliver him the ball because of this.
- Nick Malceski: Was great off half-back and kicked a ripper goal too. He really stood up in Kennelly’s place, which was great to see. His kick to handball ratio is also brilliant!
- Nat Fyfe: I’m loving watching this kid on the half-forward line. He seems to read the game beautifully and is always waiting across the half-forward line as Freo’s main link player. He is also highly skilled in the air and has a lot of confidence in himself despite his size, allowing him to play at the capacity he currently is.
Disappointing:
- Aaron Sandilands: Leading into this game many people were suggesting that big 211 could be the first AFL player to make it to 50 hitouts in a game and would therefore be a brilliant captain choice… Unfortunately, although he got himself 35 hitouts, his meagre 10 disposals dragged his score down a bit.
- Tadhg Kennelly: Copped a knee injury that took him off the field statless. Unfortunately, 2010 is the first year in which Virtual Sports have changed the rule to state that the zero WILL count towards your score… how unfortunate!
- Stephen Hill: Couldn’t handle the tag from Smith in the slightest and was hardly seen all day. Whilst he is damaging, the likes of Mundy and Duffield are probably more likely to be the ones getting attention in the future.
Blip on the Radar:
- Kepler Bradley: Has come into the side to fill Michael Johnson’s role and actually played quite well (he looked good in his other game for the season too). But seriously, Bradley is a known DT/AFL dud - this long into his career things aren’t about to change!
Essendon vs Richmond:
Looking Good:
- David Hille: I don’t envy all the people who traded Hille to Seaby after round two… Hille absolutely dominated this match - he was very strong through the midfield and smashed Richmond in the ruck. His three goals up forward were just icing on the cake. He looks to be recovering very well from his knee injury - he looks to have his speed and agility back, in fact, his fast leads in the forward line were a highlight.
- Jack Riewoldt: Riewoldt looked dangerous every time Richmond went forward and he finished the game with six goals. I love the fact he is very strong in the air, but as soon as the ball spills he has the awareness, agility and nous of a small forward.
- Paddy Ryder: Floated around the ground as second ruckman and rarely seemed to be caught with an opponent. Over the past couple of weeks it looks like he has come back into some form, but he is still very much second-fiddle to Hille.
Disappointing:
- Jake King: Why people have him in their teams is beyond me - played as a back-pocket tagger on Davey - about the only role he should be trusted with.
- Mark McVeigh: Once again, McVeigh played deep in defence and had occasional stints in the forward line, but he seems to be going nowhere near the midfield. He could have been a bargain this year, but it is time to count your losses and move him on.
- Scott Gumbleton: Really well held by McGuane, but for what it’s worth, he never looked like he stopped leading or trying, so it’s not like he had a stinker - he just couldn’t get anywhere near it!
Blip on the Radar:
- Angus Graham: Graham showed last year that he is capable of scoring the occasional big score, but his job security and immense inconsistency should rule him out of any dream team.
Melbourne vs Port Adelaide:
Looking Good:
- Brad Green: Green continues to be damaging both through the midfield and up forward, finishing with 23 disposals and three goals for the night. In a much more mature Melbourne team, Green is likely to take his game to another level.
- Travis Boak: Boak was easily the most influential Port player and used his foot much more than his hands, which was a bonus. Really stamping himself as a premium player in the making.
- Colin Sylvia: Sylvia finally showed us some form after several poor games in a row - he moved up to the HFF and had several stints through the midfield. The return on Wonaeaimirri and the form of Miller should mean Sylvia will get plenty of opportunities on the ball in the coming weeks.
Disappointing:
- Daniel Motlop: He spends too much time trying to do the special stuff and not enough time doing much else. Essentially, if he isn’t on a boundary or on someone’s shoulders, he ain’t interested!
- Jordie McKenzie: Still had his five tackles, but his average 10 disposals wasn’t enough. With the consistency he has shown throughout the rest of the season, I expect that he will bounce back pretty quickly.
- Chad Cornes: Has been deployed forward in Tredrea’s absence but was well held to only one goal. Unfortunately, for DT purposes, Cornes has always been much better in the backline, so don’t be looking at him as a bargain pick anytime soon.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brad Miller: Was great at full-forward, but just ask any Melbourne supporter when was the last time he kicked five goals straight! He may be coming into some form, but he is not the player you want!
Adelaide vs Brisbane:
Looking Good:
- Ash McGrath: Went back to the rebounding role that saw him finish 2009 strongly. He plays this role well and has the potential to pull in some big numbers. Definitely one to look closely at!
- Richard Douglas: Played through the midfield with time on the HFF and was Adelaide’s most damaging player. I still don’t trust his consistency, however he is looking better than the past couple of years.
- Nathan Van Berlo: NVB is starting to learn the art of DT in 2010, proven by a few games where he has managed a respectable number of possessions. In years past he has not been much of a ball-winner, but this year things look to be changing a bit for him.
Disappointing:
- Jonathan Brown: Clearly hampered by the injury and really needs to be rested. I would prefer him to take a zero than continually see him leak stacks of cash on my field!
- Nathan Bock: Played a much more defensive game this week on Brown. I’m not sure if his lack of rebound was due to the quality of the opposition or the role he was given, but he didn’t look much like a player I’d want in my dream team.
- Amon Buchanan: Looks a chance to be dropped again as he gave very little to the Lions cause.
Blip on the Radar:
- Brent Reilly: Reilly once tempted us as a player with lots of DT potential, but all he has shown us this year as a tagger is an ability to prevent his opposition from getting possessions, rather than getting them himself. This one game goes nowhere near suggesting that he is a player you want.
Carlton vs Hawthorn:
Looking Good:
- Luke Hodge: Dominated Carlton, and once again found himself without an opponent. I think it is his ability to play so many positions that prevents him from being matched by a tagger. Not that I’m complaining as he is in super form!
- Chris Judd: Once again Judd proved untaggable and also a very good DT prospect in the process. He is having a brilliant year and is showing no signs of slowing down - for the first time in a few years, Juddy could be a great choice in your team.
- Heath Scotland: Scotland doesn’t play the most amazing style of football, but he is a great dream teamer. He continually streamed off the half-back line with ball in hand on his way to a nifty 132 points.
Disappointing:
- Setanta O’hAilpin: Whilst he is not expected to star, the fact he has been a dominant figure in several games this year causes expectations. Unfortunately, he had only the one disposal in the first half as a full-forward, but managed to get a couple of cheapies when thrown back later in the game.
- Cyril Rioli: Tagged out of the game and had little effect on the contest. He will struggle to work through tags with his groin injuries.
- Eddie Betts: As Carlton’s ‘full-forward,’ Betts kicked no goals and looked easily beaten. He has definitely stepped up in 2010, but he is still as inconsistent as ever!
Blip on the Radar:
- Sam Jacobs: Jacobs has really impressed in his few games as replacement for the out-of-form Warnock, but I always worry how long this form will last with young ruckmen. You are better spending your money elsewhere anyway.
West Coast vs St.Kilda:
Looking Good:
- Lenny Hayes: Oh what a champ - this was my favourite individual performance of the weekend. Lenny worked his heart out, especially in an inspirational third quarter where he willed the Saints to lift. He is in stellar form and it is not yet too late to get on board!
- Brendon Goddard: BJ really lifted in the second half when moved to CHF. As usual he worked really hard in the contests and is consistently the go-to player before heading into the forward-50, equalling plenty of marks and kicks.
- Adam Selwood: Tagged Goddard in parts, but won his own ball very well. Despite his role involving preventing another player from getting the ball, he is always willing to win his own ball and be used as an outside option too.
Disappointing:
- Mark LeCras: Was smashed by Raph Clarke to the point of frustration. He had very little effect on the game and just couldn’t get into it when it counted.
- Nick Heyne: After his second game, eyes will look upon this ‘bubble-boy,’ however I feel his spot in the team may not be very safe. Whilst playing well in patches, he did lack consistency across the four quarters, which may end up seeing him make way for a more senior player.
- Nic Naitanui: Played well in the ruck, but was beaten for smarts around the ground by Gardiner and McEvoy. He was even trialled as an on-baller in the last quarter to try and get him into the match, yet this still didn’t work.
Blip on the Radar:
- Ben McKinley: Kicked four goals in the first half and then was hardly sighted again. He is a player known for his low work-rate when the chips don’t fall his way and he proved this tonight. When the Eagles are up he will fire, but if there are struggling, he’s not going to be anywhere near it.
This post currently has
20 comments ·
Add a comment