Footy Tragic
Teams Round 16
ADELAIDE v GEELONG CATS
Adelaide
B: Graham Johncock, Ben Rutten, Scott Stevens
HB: Brad Symes, Phil Davis, Simon Goodwin
C: Michael Doughty, Nathan van Berlo, David Mackay
HF: Richard Douglas, Ricky Henderson, Matthew Jaensch
F: Patrick Dangerfield, Kurt Tippett, Taylor Walker
R: Ivan Maric, Scott Thompson, Brent Reilly
Int: Jonathon Grffin, Bernie Vince, Andrew McLeod, Rory Sloane
Emg: James Sellar, Jason Porplyzia, Nathan Bock
In: McLeod, Mackay
Out: Tony Armstrong, Jason Porplyzia
- A couple of strong inclusions to Adelaide’s lineup. Mackay is good to see back, although i doubt he is in too many teams now after the period of time he is missed. McLeod is a speculative one – a lot of people thought he would play SANFL this week, so is a chance to be a late out. Then again, you don’t play Rolls Royces on those grounds, so perhaps he will play…
- Armstrong again makes way, showing ball-winning doesn’t guarantee a game. The Porpoise is out again thanks to his average recent form.
Geelong Cats
B: Josh Hunt, Matthew Scarlett, Tom Lonergan
HB: Corey Enright, Harry Taylor, James Kelly
C: Andrew Mackie, Cameron Ling, Joel Corey
HF: Paul Chapman, James Podsiadly, Gary Ablett
F: Mathew Stokes, Cameron Mooney, Travis Varcoe
Foll: Brad Ottens, Joel Selwood, Jimmy Bartel
I/C: Shannon Byrnes, Mark Blake, David Wojcinski, Joel Corey
Emg: Tom Hawkins, Taylor Hunt, Mitch Duncan
In: Corey, Mooney
Out: Mitch Duncan, Darren Milburn (general soreness)
- Corey back, but his missing last week is proof that he is probably a bit too much of a risk this year. Mooney also returns from suspension, whilst Stevie J appears to miss another game. Hawkins will play VFL this week.
- Duncan is omitted, whilst Milburn is the first of the Cats veterans to be rested.
COLLINGWOOD v ST KILDA
Collingwood
B: Heath Shaw, Simon Prestigiacomo, Ben Reid
HB: Harry O’Brien, Tyson Goldsack, Alan Toovey
C: Sharrod Wellingham, Dane Swan, Jarryd Blair
HF: Luke Ball, Chris Dawes, Leon Davis
F: Dayne Beams, Leigh Brown, Steele Sidebottom
Foll: Darren Jolly, Scott Pendlebury, Dale Thomas
I/C: Alan Didak, Ben Johnson, Tarkyn Lockyer, Brent Macaffer
Emg: John Anthony, Josh Fraser, Luke Rounds
In: Davis, Macaffer
Out: Travis Cloke (suspended), John Anthony
- Two tall forwards omitted/suspended for Collingwood, yet still no Fraser or Medhurst. Writing on the wall perhaps? Cloke will miss two weeks with suspension, whilst Anthony is simply dropped.
- Davis will return from a neck injury – I wouldn’t be counting on a season-changing game from him though…
St Kilda
B: Zac Dawson, Jason Blake, Sam Gilbert
HB: Jason Gram, Sam Fisher, James Gwilt
C: Brendon Goddard, Nick Dal Santo, Farren Ray
HF: Clinton Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Leigh Montagna
F: Andrew McQualter, Nick Riewoldt, Stephen Milne
Foll: Michael Gardiner, Lenny Hayes, Adam Schneider
I/C: Jack Steven, Adam Pattison, Brett Peake, Jarryn Geary
Emg: Ben McEvoy, Sean Dempster, David Armitage
In: Koschitzke, Goddard
Out: Sean Dempster, Ben McEvoy
- Kosi returns, although it is still speculative whether he will play – Lyon said mid-week he would be named regardless and they would see how he pulls up before the game before making the final decision. Goddard also returns from the Flu.
- McEvoy is dropped in favour of Pattison, who played his best game for the club last week – perhaps this could also be read as a sign that Kosi will be a late withdrawal.
HAWTHORN v BRISBANE LIONS
Hawthorn
B: Brent Guerra, Ben Stratton, Josh Gibson
HB: Thomas Murphy, Stephen Gilham, Grant Birchall
C: Clinton Young, Sam Mitchell, Chance Bateman
HF: Cyril Rioli, Lance Franklin, Michael Osborne
F: Shaun Burgoyne, Jarryd Roughead, Campbell Brown
Foll: Brent Renouf, Luke Hodge, Xavier Ellis
I/C: Jordan Lewis, Carl Peterson, Wayde Skipper, Brendan Whitecross
Emg: Jordan Lisle, Shane Savage, Brad Sewell
In: Mitchell, Whitecross
Out: Brad Sewell, Ryan Schoenmakers
- Two pretty high profile omissions for Hawthorn! As far as I am aware, neither man is injured, so it is certainly a big statement, especially the omission of Sewell, who has certainly been well down on his 2009 efforts.
- Mitchell has been named after missing just one game with a broken finger. His spot in the team is still speculative, so make sure you have emergency cover for him.
- Also, Buddy has been named despite rolling his ankle at training yesterday. They will give him until the first bounce to prove his fitness.
Brisbane Lions
B: Tom Collier, Daniel Merrett, Ashley McGrath
HB: Daniel Rich, Joel Patfull, Travis Johnstone
C: Jack Redden, Tom Rockliff, Justin Sherman
HF: James Polkinghorne, Jonathan Brown, Luke Power
F: Todd Banfield, Brendan Fevola, Brent Staker
Foll: Mitchell Clark, Michael Rischitelli, Jared Brennan
I/C: Matthew Leuenberger, Pearce Hanley, Amon Buchanan, Matt Maguire
Emg: James Hawksley, Aaron Cornelius, Jesse O’Brien
In: Brown, Maguire
Out: Aaron Cornelius, Simon Black (ankle)
- Michael Voss is true to form, bringing injured skipper, Jon Brown back one week early from injury. Definitely a welcome inclusion to plenty of DTs though! Maguire is also named after impressing last week in the QAFL.
- Cornelius, their leading goal-kicker of the past three weeks is the unlucky omission, whilst Black has an ankle injury and will miss.
ESSENDON v WEST COAST
Essendon
B: Dustin Fletcher, Michael Hurley, Heath Hocking
HB: Courtenay Dempsey, Cale Hooker, Brent Stanton
C: Mark McVeigh, Jobe Watson, Kyle Reimers
HF: Alwyn Davey, Scott Gumbleton, Angus Monfries
F: Patrick Ryder, Jay Neagle, Travis Colyer
Foll: Tom Bellchambers, Jake Melksham, Jason Winderlich
I/C: David Zaharakis, Sam Lonergan, Nathan Lovett-Murray, Ben Howlett
Emg: Bachar Houli, Brent Prismall, David Myers
In: Gumbleton, Melksham, Fletcher
Out: Andrew Welsh (groin), Ricky Dyson (knee), Leroy Jetta (suspension)
- Gumby returns after being a late withdrawal last week, as does Melksham and Fletcher who has now served his three week suspension.
- Two injuries and a suspension force the changes with Welsh, Dyson and Jetta those missing out.
West Coast
B: Will Schofield, Eric MacKenzie, Brad Sheppard
HB: Beau Waters, Mitchell Brown, Shannon Hurn
C: Matt Rosa, Matt Priddis, Andrew Embley
HF: Andrew Strijk, Josh Kennedy, Brad Ebert
F: Nic Naitanui, Quinten Lynch, Mark LeCras
Foll: Dean Cox, Adam Selwood, Chris Masten
I/C: Ashton Hams, Scott Selwood, Ashley Smith, Lewis Stevenson
Emg: Tim Houlihan, Koby Stevens, Callum Wilson
In: Hurn
Out: Brett Jones
- Hurn makes his way back into the squad after spending two weeks on the sidelines with injury.
- The main news though is the naming of Waters, who was suspected to miss after corking his hamstring. Fortunately, the man is tough as nails and can play through the pain!
- In other good news, all of Smith, Stevenson and Hams keeps their spots.
WESTERN BULLDOGS v PORT ADELAIDE
Western Bulldogs
B: Jarrod Harbrow, Brian Lake, Dale Morris
HB: Ryan Hargrave, Tom Williams, Lindsay Gilbee
C: Ryan Griffen, Matthew Boyd, Nathan Eagleton
HF: Robert Murphy, Andrejs Everitt, Callan Ward
F: Shaun Higgins, Jarrad Grant, Daniel Giansiracusa
Foll: Ben Hudson, Daniel Cross, Adam Cooney
I/C: Jordan Roughead, Easton Wood, Liam Picken, Brad Johnson
Emg: Andrew Hooper, Liam Jones, Brodie Moles
In: Everitt, Eagleton
Out: Brennan Stack (hamstring), Barry Hall (ankle)
- Barry Hall is out with a sore ankle and is expected to miss 1-2 weeks, whilst Stack will miss around 3 weeks.
- Brad Johnson is making the trip to Darwin, whilst Aker will miss again, despite completing his club suspension.
Port Adelaide
B: Paul Stewart, Jackson Trengove, Nick Salter
HB: Steven Salopek, Troy Chaplin, Matt Thomas
C: Kane Cornes, Domenic Cassisi, Travis Boak
HF: Justin Westhoff, Jay Schulz, David Rodan
F: Jason Davenport, Daniel Motlop, Brett Ebert
Foll: Dean Brogan, Danyle Pearce, Tom Logan
I/C: Mitch Banner, Matt Broadbent, Cameron Hitchcock, Jay Nash
Emg: Andrew Moore, Scott Harding, Daniel Stewart
In: Davenport, Nash, Schulz
Out: Atipate Carlile (back), Josh Carr, Daniel Stewart
- OUT: Mark Williams; IN: Matthew Primus
- Davenport is the main inclusion into the Port side this week, besides their new Coach.
- The statement towards youth has already been made by the dropping of Carr and the non-selection of Chad Cornes, despite his fitness.
CARLTON v SYDNEY SWANS
Carlton
B: Aaron Joseph, Michael Jamison, Andrew Walker
HB: Jordan Russell, Paul Bower, Bryce Gibbs
C: Heath Scotland, Kade Simpson, Kane Lucas
HF: Andrew Carrazzo, Lachie Henderson, Jeff Garlett
F: Chris Yarran, Jarrad Waite, Eddie Betts
Foll: Sam Jacobs, Chris Judd, Marc Murphy
I/C (from): Dennis Armfield, Marcus Davies, David Ellard, Shaun Grigg, Shaun Hampson, Mitch Robinson, Robert Warnock
In: Waite, Grigg, Warnock, Ellard, Davies, Lucas
Out: Ryan Houlihan (knee), Bret Thornton, Setanta O’hAilpin
- Ratten has rung the changes as Carlton with Thornton and O’hAilpin dropped.
- There will likely be even more changes once the final teams have been named with plenty of average performers sitting on the extended bench.
- Waite will return, whilst plenty will be hoping for the selection of Warnock over Hampson after he was one of the Bullants’ best afield last week in the VFL.
Sydney Swans
B: Rhyce Shaw, Lewis Roberts-Thomson, Nick Smith
HB: Paul Bevan, Heath Grundy, Tadhg Kennelly
C: Nick Malceski, Brett Kirk, Kieren Jack
HF: Daniel Hannebery, Ryan O’Keefe, Josh Kennedy
F: Ben McGlynn, Adam Goodes, Jarred Moore
Foll: Shane Mumford, Jude Bolton, Jarrad McVeigh
I/C (from): Trent Dennis-Lane, Brett Meredith, Mike Pyke, Ted Richards, Martin Mattner, Lewis Jetta, Jesse White
In: Mattner, White, Jetta
- No outs yet for Sydney, but Mattner, White and Jetta have all been named. Mattner will likely play, whilst Jetta was BOG in the weekend’s VFL game.
- Expect Meredith, White and TDL to make the emergency list.
RICHMOND v NORTH MELBOURNE
Richmond
B: Chris Newman, Will Thursfield, David Astbury
HB: Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio, Daniel Connors
C: Jeromey Webberley, Ben Cousins, Shane Edwards
HF: Matt White, Jack Riewoldt, Richard Tambling
F: Robin Nahas, Tyrone Vickery, Andrew Collins
Foll: Angus Graham, Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin
I/C (from): Kelvin Moore, Jake King, Mitch Farmer, Luke McGuane, Dean Polo, Jayden Post, Alex Rance
In: McGuane, Polo, Tambling, Rance, Post, Cousins
Out: Daniel Jackson (suspension), Ben Nason (soreness), Ben Griffiths (shoulder)
- A few forced changes for Richmond after a big win is disappointing, although it at least makes room for the returning Cousins and Tambling. Post will also definitely play, suggesting that McGuane, Polo and Rance are likely to make the emergency list if no other changes are to be made.
- Webberley has also been named which is very good news for his owners.
North Melbourne
B: Michael Firrito, Scott Thompson, Brady Rawlings
HB: Robbie Tarrant, Nathan Grima, Daniel Pratt
C: Leigh Adams, Brent Harvey, Ryan Bastinac
HF: Lindsay Thomas, Lachlan Hansen, Ben Warren
F: Daniel Wells, Todd Goldstein, Sam Wright
Foll: Hamish McIntosh, Andrew Swallow, Levi Greenwood
I/C (from): Ed Lower, Ben Cunnington, Gavin Urquhart, Aaron Edwards, Matt Campbell, Jamie Macmillan, Leigh Harding
In: Harding, Edwards, Grima, Urquhart, Macmillan
Out: Drew Petrie (foot), Cruize Garlett (calf)
New: Jamie Macmillan (Oakleigh Chargers)
- Two outs for North, one of which is Petrie who played a week too early and re-injured his foot AGAIN, meaning he will now miss the remainder of the year. I expect Edwards will step into his forward spot this week when the final teams are named.
- Jamie Macmillan (Not to be confused with Jamie Macmillan-Pittard from Port) has been named for his debut and is a good chance to play. He was the 37th pick in last years draft and is a medium sized midfielder. In the TAC cup last year he averaged 19 disposals and 4 tackles per game whilst playing for the Oakleigh chargers. Then, when playing for Vic Metro in the carnival, he averaged 15 disposals and 5 tackles a game – the best in the squad. He has a good sized body which should be capable of competing at AFL level, although I’d want to see him in action before trading him in.
FREMANTLE v MELBOURNE
Fremantle
B: Dylan Roberton, Alex Silvagni, Kepler Bradley
HB: Matthew de Boer, Luke McPharlin, Roger Hayden
C: Garrick Ibbotson, David Mundy, Nathan Fyfe
HF: Jay van Berlo, Matthew Pavlich, Stephen Hill
F: Adam McPhee, Michael Johnson, Hayden Ballantyne
Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Ryan Crowley, Paul Duffield
I/C (from): Anthony Morabito, Clancee Pearce, Chris Tarrant, Rhys Palmer, Nick Suban, Greg Broughton, Paul Hasleby
In: McPharlin, Broughton, Fyfe, Tarrant
Out: Tim Ruffles
- Some great ins for Freo, with all of McPharlin, Broughton, Fyfe and Tarrant best-22 players. Their inclusion will obviously see a few players missing out, with Pearce, Suban and Hasleby the ones most likely. Certainly keep an eye on the final teams on Friday night if you have any of these guys!
Melbourne
B: Colin Garland, Jared Rivers, Clint Bartram
HB: Jordie McKenzie, James Frawley, Cameron Bruce
C: Jamie Bennell, Nathan Jones, Brad Green
HF: Lynden Dunn, Jack Watts, Tom Scully
F: Colin Sylvia, Matthew Bate, Liam Jurrah
Foll: Mark Jamar, Brent Moloney, Aaron Davey
I/C (from): Joel Macdonald, Kyle Cheney, Paul Johnson, Rohan Bail, Addam Maric, Matthew Warnock, Cale Morton
In: Rohan Bail, Matthew Warnock, Addam Maric, Cale Morton
Out: Jack Trengove (hip)
- A few good inclusions for Melbourne, but one very big out in Trengove – this will certainly hurt plenty of teams, including Melbourne!
- Morton and Bail are named on the bench and a good chance to make the cut with Macdonald, Cheney and Johnson all skating on thin ice.
19 Comments on Teams Round 16
Once again, the team wrap is up, reviewed and complete before the AFL website, Herald Sun and The Age!
well done frist up and best around.
(i thought you would have mentioned something about Ben nason)
Whats Jordan Roughead’s job security like? (thinking about downgrading hille to him)
Am I crazy to be considering playing Nat Fyfe over J.Brown?
also, with the rules stating the lowest emergency plays i ahve some trouble in my defence. Sheppard and Strijk are providing cover to Waters, Broughton & Maguire. I think Maguire is definite – but broughton i’m worried about – but don’t want to miss his score if he does play. sigh… any advice?
Should i go a straight swap Hille to Jolly or downgrade Hille (to Roughead/other) upgrade bower (to goddard)and have 300k in the bank to upgrade other players(eg.shaw/carrots to lake)? ? ?
(i have 5 trades left)
5 trades left I wouldn’t do anything too radical, straight swap FTW.
I’m currently coming 3rd in my league, top 2 get paid overall (worked out on total score not finals system) and given the top guy has almost an identical team I decided to take a risk with my final upgrade – no one will like this – Nason to Newman. Symes may have been a more consistent idea but it’s the business end – time to take some risks.
Holman, i’m actually liking the Newman trade. I looked at him a couple of weeks back but couldn’t bring myself to do it so kudos to you for having the coconuts to pull the trigger on him. With the exception of Collingwood and St.Kilda, Richmond’s run home is surprisingly not that bad, and it’s worth noting that Chris has had some strong scores against the tougher sides this year as well so it must make you a little more confident there.
I need some advice for a defender upgrade too, which most will think is a waste, but this bloke’s been grinding my patience for weeks now …. Rhyce Shaw.
He was one of my nuffy picks at the start of the year with the idea that with the return of Kennelly and Malceski, he might slip under the radar a bit, but unfortunately that punt didn’t come off as well as i’d hoped, and he has been ordinary at best.
Anyway, story is – sitting 5th, 4 trades left, (which in all rationale, should be saved for finals) all 3 games coming home could really go down to the wire as the league is quite competitive, but i’m really hoping for a top 4 finish.
I can off-load Rhyce for a 10-20+ point advantage and look at brining in a Scotland, Gilbee, Lovett-Murray or Russell?
Very tempting.. only 3 trades for 6 weeks though.. too dangerous?
Very interested to hear some thoughts.
Firstly let me say I love your sight – I look forward to reading each day.
Looking for some advise… I can’t decide which 2 players to start on the field between Pods, Tippett or Brown. The 3rd will be an emergency.
Pods form has been up and down.
Tippett has found some form in his last 2.
And obviously Brown is returning injury.
Holman i have been thinking about Newman. from what i understand he plays a role a little like lake, he has i good kick to handball ratio and avg’s about 9 marks a game and sometimes kicks a few goals. Id like to hear from one of the footy tragic boys about him.
What do you think would be the best combo for me:
1. Hille to Jolly, Bower to Newman (3 trades left,$3,600)
2. Hille to Jolly (4 trades left,$50,700)
3. Hille to Jordan Roughead, Bower to Goddard (3 trades left,$153,400)
4. Hille to Tippet (4 trades left,$128,900)
thanks
Wilson 10-20 point advantage isn’t really worth a trade
in saying this i have only been playing DT since this time last year
Those plays you mentioned can also have very average scores
Hey, I actually quite like Newman as an option, as i discussed in this week’s weekly wrap. He is a designated kicker off half-back for Richmond so will regularly attract the ball. Also, the fact he does play a negating role on an opponent too, it means he wont be tagged. No as prolific as Lake, but yes, same role.
As for the rucks, i think Jolly is the best pickup… I don’t like relying on Skipper, even if it means you can afford Goddard. I’d prefer to see you trust Bower, or move to Newman. This could even be given another week to see how Bower does go – Newman shouldnt shoot up in price much this week. But i’d definitely go Hille to Jolly though.
And Wilson, as for getting rid of rhyce shaw, all the names you listed are similarly inconsistent. The choice of the bunch is probably Scotland though. He at least has the runs on the board – the others are proven inconsistent scorers.
Hope this helps
thanks Toby.
Buddy is out as well:
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/98339/default.aspx
Thanks guys, you don’t sound that convincing about my Rhyce trade.. haha
Scotland is very tempting at that price but his recent form doesn’t do much to suggest he can get back to his early season form, which is a worry.
Blues play the Swans this week too, which is never that promising as far as DT output…
Hmmm… decisions…
My tough choice this week is whether to start Brown over Tippett/Pods. Tippett has been good, but I’m expecting Scarlett will get him. Pods not so great away from Skilled, but might go alright against Adelaide with plenty of ball coming at him out of the middle.
Thoughts?
Greg, RE:pods here are some stats that might help
Overall Average: 87.8
Top 8 Average: 73.0 (from 6 games)
Bottom 8 Average: 102.5 (from 6 games)
Adelaide are a bottom 8 side, so lets hope for 102.5 :)
They’re a bottom 8 side who, like Richmond, are playing like a top 8 side…
that being said, Brown is a punt in my book. I would expect Pods to do well against us…
Yeah I’m actually thinking of putting Pods on the bench. He will have Rutten on him all game, who last week smashed Josh Kennedy, round 14 Gumbleton and Round 13 Watts… haha… so in saying that, they havent really been big scalps…
Hell, i don’t know! Maybe leaving Brown on the bench is the best idea as he is the one we are probably most in the dark about!
Rumours are flying around that Ablett will be a late withdrawal from tonights game! Be very careful naming him captain if this is the case!
Never mind… He’s been named! Phew
That would be Jasper MacMillan-Pittard not Jamie ;). Love your write-ups though.
Leave a comment on Teams Round 16
You must be logged in to post a comment.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI